Jun 28, 2026 PSA 9 $36 e b a y
2004 TOPPS PREMIERE PROSPECTS #PP5 ELI MANNING ROOKIE PSA 9 #PP 5 Jun 26, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
2004 Topps - 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning (RC) New York Giants GOAT🔥🔥🔥 #PP5 Jun 23, 2026 Ungraded $7 e b a y
Eli Manning 2004 Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 New York Giants - Free Shipping #PP5 Jun 16, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Topps #PP5 ELI MANNING Premiere Prospects New York Giants C005595 #PP 5 Jun 14, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 #PP5 May 27, 2026 PSA 8 $25 e b a y
2004 Topps - 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 (RC) PSA 8 #PP5 May 23, 2026 Ungraded $7 e b a y
2004 Topps - 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 (RC) #PP5 May 22, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
2004 Topps 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning RC #PP5 New York Giants #PP5 May 11, 2026 PSA 9 $28 e b a y
2004 TOPPS PREMIERE PROSPECTS #PP5 ELI MANNING PSA 9 #PP5 May 10, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
2004 Topps - 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 (RC) New York Giants #PP5 May 8, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
Eli Manning 2004 Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 New York Giants #PP5 May 5, 2026 Ungraded $0 e b a y
2004 Topps #PP5 Eli Manning Premiere Prospects #PP5 May 1, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Topps 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 Rookie RC #PP5 Apr 27, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
2004 Topps #PP5 Eli Manning RC Rookie Card Premiere Prospects New York Giants #PP5 Apr 17, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Topps #PP5 Eli Manning Premiere Prospects RC #PP5 Apr 10, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
Eli Manning 2004 Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 New York Giants #PP5 Apr 7, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
2004 Topps - 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 (RC) #PP5 Apr 6, 2026 Ungraded $8 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning RC New York Giants #PP5 *Noles2148* #PP5 Mar 20, 2026 Ungraded $7 e b a y
2004 Topps - Premiere Prospects #PP5 Eli Manning #PP5 Mar 17, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects Rookie RC #PP5 Giants Mar 12, 2026 Ungraded $7 e b a y
2004 Topps - 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 (RC) and Bonus Card #PP5 Mar 9, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects #PP5 Rookie Giants FX4251 #PP5 Mar 9, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning Rookie #PP5 #PP 5 Feb 24, 2026 Ungraded $7 e b a y
2004 Topps - Premiere Prospects #PP5 Eli Manning #PP5 Feb 24, 2026 PSA 8 $25 e b a y
ELI MANNING 2004 Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 NY Giants Rookie RC PSA-8 NM-MT #PP5 Feb 11, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects #PP5 Rookie RC Giants NM+ #PP5 Feb 9, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 Rookie Card RC #PP 5 Jan 25, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning Rookie New York Giants #PP5 Football #PP5 Jan 25, 2026 PSA 8.5 $15 e b a y
2004 TOPPS PREMIERE PROSPECTS #PP5 ELI MANNING RC POP 3 PSA 8.5 Jan 24, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
2004 Topps Football Eli Manning RC Premiere Prospects #PP5 #PP 5 Jan 22, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
2004 TOPPS ELI MANNING PREMIERE PROSPECTS NEW YORK GIANTS #PP5 Jan 17, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 TOPPS ELI MANNING PREMIERE PROSPECTS NEW YORK GIANTS #PP5 Jan 15, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects #PP5 Rookie RC Giants #PP5 Jan 14, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects #PP5 Rookie RC Giants #PP 5 Jan 10, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
2004 Eli Manning Rookie Card Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 New York Giants B #PP5 Jan 7, 2026 SGC 8 $10 e b a y
2004 Eli Manning Topps Premiere Prospects Rookie Card SGC 8 NY Giants #PP5 #PP 5 Jan 5, 2026 PSA 9 $25 e b a y
2004 Topps - Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 (RC) PSA 9 Mint #PP5 Jan 3, 2026 PSA 9 $25 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning Rookie RC #PP5 PSA 9 Mint Giants #PP5 Aug 27, 2025 Grade 9 $15 e b a y
ELI MANNING 2004 Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 NY Giants RC Beckett 9 Mint #PP5 Aug 3, 2025 PSA 10 $160 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 Rookie Gem PSA 10 #PP5 Jul 29, 2025 PSA 10 $125 e b a y
2004 ELI MANNING Topps Premiere Prospects #PP5 **ROOKIE CARD / GIANTS / PSA 10** #PP5 May 6, 2025 PSA 8 $13 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects Rookie RC #PP5 Giants PSA 8 Mar 12, 2025 PSA 8 $25 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning Insert Rookie #PP5 PSA 8 #PP5 Feb 27, 2025 PSA 10 $97 e b a y
2004 Topps #PP5 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning (RC) PSA 10 New York Giants #PP 5 Feb 1, 2025 PSA 8 $25 e b a y
2004 Topps 2004 Premiere Prospects Eli Manning #PP5 PSA 8 Rookie RC #PP5 Jan 30, 2025 PSA 9 $25 e b a y
2004 TOPPS PREMIERE PROSPECTS #PP5 ELI MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9 #PP5 Jan 18, 2025 PSA 9 $30 e b a y
PSA 9 MINT 2004 Topps Premiere Prospects ELI MANNING Rookie RC #PP5 HOF'er Jan 15, 2025 PSA 9 $24 e b a y
2004 Topps Premiere Prospects Eli Manning Rookie #PP5 PSA MINT 9 #PP 5 Jan 4, 2025 PSA 10 $100 e b a y
2004 Topps - Premiere Prospects #PP5 Eli Manning (RC) PSA 10 #PP5 Jan 4, 2025 PSA 8 $20 e b a y
2004 Topps Eli Manning Premiere Prospects Rookie RC #PP5 PSA 8 #PP5 
Estimated market value — upgrade to Collector to unlock
