1986 McDonald's All Stars Card Prices & Most Valuable Cards — American Football | PopHunter

1986 McDonald's All Stars

68 cards · top card $429 (Walter Payton)

Ranked by value — top graded price, falling back to raw. Open in the full scanner →

68 cards

Rank	Card	Top grade	Total pop	30D	Opportunity?
#1	Walter Payton#34Green	$429PSA 10	—	0.0%	47.8
#2	Joe Montana#16Black	$300PSA 10	—	0.0%	42.8
#3	Walter Payton#34Black	$281PSA 10	—	+0.1%	42.8
#4	Joe Montana#16Green	$246PSA 10	—	-0.0%	47.8
#5	Dan Marino#13Blue	$183PSA 10	—	0.0%	50.8
#6	Roger Craig#33Gold, Orange	$120PSA 10	—	0.0%	47.8
#7	Dan Marino#13Green	$114PSA 10	—	0.0%	50.8
#8	Ozzie Newsome#82Black	$111PSA 10	—	0.0%	50.0
#9	Joe Montana#16Gold, Orange	$110BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#10	Joe Montana#16Blue	$109BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#11	Lawrence Taylor#56Green	$97PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#12	Randy White#54Green	$85PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#13	Ozzie Newsome#82Green	$71PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#14	Roger Craig#33Black	$65PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#15	Walter Payton#34Gold, Orange	$64BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#16	Howie Long#75Black	$64BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#17	Walter Payton#34Blue	$62BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#18	Anthony Munoz#78Blue	$60PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#19	Phil Simms#11Blue	$59PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#20	Lawrence Taylor#56Black	$52BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#21	Marcus Allen#32Blue	$50PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#22	Ozzie Newsome#82Blue	$45BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#23	Phil Simms#11Gold, Orange	$44PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#24	Jim McMahon#9Green	$42BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#25	Kevin Mack#34Green	$41PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#26	Mike Quick#82Gold, Orange	$40PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#27	Dan Marino#13Gold, Orange	$37BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#28	Dan Marino#13Black	$36BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#29	Art Monk#81Black	$34BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#30	Mike Webster#52Black	$33BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#31	Dan Fouts#14Blue	$31BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#32	Jim McMahon#9Gold, Orange	$30Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#33	Dan Fouts#14Black	$28BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#34	Art Monk#81Blue	$25BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#35	Dan Fouts#14Green	$24BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#36	Mike Munchak#63Gold, Orange	$24BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#37	Lawrence Taylor#56Blue	$23BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#38	Phil Simms#11Green	$22BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#39	Dan Fouts#14Gold, Orange	$21BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#40	Randy White#54Gold, Orange	$18BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#41	Howie Long#75Green	$17BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#42	Gerald Riggs#42Green	$16BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#43	Joe Jacoby#66Green	$16PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#44	Ozzie Newsome#82Gold, Orange	$15BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#45	Howie Long#75Gold, Orange	$13BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#46	Mike Webster#52Green	$12BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#47	Randy White#54Black	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#48	Mike Quick#82Green	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#49	Rulon Jones#75Green	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#50	Anthony Munoz#78Green	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#51	Joey Browner#47Blue	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#52	Deron Cherry#20Green	$11PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#53	Lawrence Taylor#56Gold, Orange	$10Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#54	E.J. Junior#54Green	$10PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#55	Chris Hinton#75Green	$10PSA 10	—	—	50.0
#56	Mike Munchak#63Blue	$9BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#57	Gerald Riggs#42Blue	$9BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#58	Marcus Allen#32Green	$8BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#59	Mark Gastineau#99Green	$8BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#60	Roger Craig#33Blue	$8Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#61	Mike Quick#82Blue	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#62	Rulon Jones#75Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#63	Kenny Easley#45Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#64	Kevin Mack#34Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#65	Mark Gastineau#99Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#66	Joey Browner#47Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#67	Marcus Allen#32Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#68	Anthony Munoz#78Gold, Orange	$1Raw	—	—	56.0