1991 Pro Set Card Prices & Most Valuable Cards — American Football | PopHunter

1991 Pro Set

200 cards · top card $350 (Bill Belichick)

Ranked by value — top graded price, falling back to raw. Open in the full scanner →

200 cards

Rank	Card	Top grade	Total pop	30D	Opportunity?
#1	Bill Belichick#126	$350PSA 10	—	0.0%	57.8
#2	John Randle#835	$202PSA 10	—	+1.1%	54.3
#3	Art McNally#352	$174PSA 10	3	0.0%	65.3
#4	Dixon Edwards#766	$154PSA 10	1	0.0%	52.8
#5	Brett Favre#762	$150PSA 10	—	0.0%	56.8
#6	Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson#335No Logo	$149PSA 10	—	0.0%	47.8
#7	Neil O'Donnell#845	$145PSA 10	—	0.0%	45.8
#8	Walter Payton#1Team 34	$121PSA 10	7	0.0%	68.8
#9	Red Grange#2Special	$119PSA 10	4	0.0%	71.0
#10	Jerome Brown#392	$108PSA 10	2	0.0%	55.8
#11	Bruce Smith#417	$101PSA 10	—	0.0%	55.5
#12	Derrick Thomas#19Error Bills Helmet on Front	$100PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#13	Bill Parcells#72	$99PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#14	Randall Cunningham#24	$97PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#15	Earl Campbell#27	$94PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#16	Barry Sanders#502	$92PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#17	Mike Utley#849	$92PSA 10	—	—	51.8
#18	Emmitt Smith#1	$90PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#19	Whitney Houston#350	$88PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#20	Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson#335No NFLPA Logo on Back	$88PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#21	Mike Ditka#108	$83PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#22	Steve Young#296	$81PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#23	Roger Craig#21	$81PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#24	Howie Long#191	$80PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#25	Bo Jackson#335Barry Sanders	$75PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#26	Joe Montana#387	$73PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#27	Emmitt Smith#485	$71PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#28	Barry Sanders#388	$66PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#29	Herschel Walker#44	$63PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#30	Barry Sanders, Bo Jackson#335NFLPA Logo on Back	$61PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#31	Bo Jackson#42	$58PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#32	Jerry Rice#654	$58PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#33	Warren Moon#9	$58PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#34	Raghib Ismail#36	$56PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#35	Ozzie Newsome#699	$56PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#36	Derrick Thomas#188	$55PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#37	Emmitt Smith#1Offensive Roy	$53PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#38	Lawrence Taylor#602	$51PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#39	Ed West#513	$50PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#40	Alvin Harper#741	$50PSA 10	—	—	54.8
#41	Russell Maryland#32	$50PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#42	Joe Montana#653	$49PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#43	Warren Moon#414	$49PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#44	Barry Sanders#10	$49PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#45	Ricky Watters#774	$49PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#46	Herman Moore#739	$46PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#47	Jerry Rice#379	$45PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#48	Art Shell#4	$42PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#49	Jerry Rice#11	$42PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#50	Ty Detmer#37	$41PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#51	Warren Moon#167	$40PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#52	Ed McCaffrey#812	$40PSA 10	—	—	51.8
#53	Aeneas Williams#788	$38PSA 10	—	—	51.8
#54	Jim Kelly#8	$38PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#55	Erik Williams#799	$37PSA 10	—	—	57.0
#56	U.S. Troops#351NFL Newsreel	$36BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#57	Jimmy Johnson#405	$36PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#58	Marty Schottenheimer#189	$35BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#59	Jake Reed#797	$35PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#60	Troy Aikman#128	$35PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#61	Bo Jackson#346	$34PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#62	Emmitt Smith#1Gazette	$33PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#63	John Elway#138	$32PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#64	The Bo And Barry Show#335	$31PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#65	Randall Cunningham#256	$31PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#66	Barry Sanders#39	$31PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#67	Don Shula#216	$30PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#68	Joe Montana#3	$30PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#69	Don Beebe#442	$30PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#70	Lawrence Taylor#394	$30PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#71	Jimmy Johnson#135	$30PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#72	Reggie White#390	$29PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#73	Marv Levy#90	$27PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#74	Eric Dickerson#175	$27PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#75	Dan Marino#210	$26PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#76	Jeff Graham#775	$25PSA 10	—	—	48.8
#77	Marcus Allen#45	$25PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#78	Bruce Smith#83	$25PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#79	Dan Marino#25	$25PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#80	Joe Montana#329	$24PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#81	Deion Sanders#98	$24PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#82	Tex Schramm#30	$23PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#83	Art Monk#22	$23PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#84	Sterling Sharpe#161	$21BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#85	Mike Singletary#5	$21PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#86	Mike Singletary#396	$21PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#87	Lawrence Taylor#336	$20PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#88	WARREN MOON#370	$20Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#89	Ronnie Lott#400	$20PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#90	Rod Woodson#278	$20Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#91	Michael Irvin#132	$20PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#92	Todd Marinovich#753	$20Grade 8	—	—	48.8
#93	Tim Brown#40Uer: Missing Copyright on Back	$19BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#94	Matt Brock#505	$19BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#95	Thurman Thomas#13	$19PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#96	Roman Phifer#760	$16PSA 10	—	—	48.8
#97	Chuck Webb#810	$14BGS 9.5	—	—	57.0
#98	Henry Jones#755	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	57.0
#99	Jarrod Bunch#756	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	57.0
#100	Kent Hull#412	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#101	Eric Moten#776	$10PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#102	Jim Kelly#78	$10Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#103	Judd Garrett#710	$10PSA 10	—	—	48.8
#104	Carlos Jenkins#794	$8BGS 9.5	—	—	57.0
#105	Think About It :Troy Aikman#372	$8Grade 8	—	—	47.8
#106	Jesse Campbell#777	$5BGS 9.5	—	—	57.0
#107	Bob Dahl#801	$4BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#108	Santa Clause	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#109	Mike Gann#435	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#110	DAVID DANIELS#803	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#111	Jim Kelly#78No NFLPA Logo	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#112	Mark Higgs#831	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#113	Keith Traylor#790	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#114	Huey Richardson#744	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#115	Mike Croel#850Rookie of the Year	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#116	Nick Bell#772	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#117	Reggie Johnson#759	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#118	Stan Thomas#751	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#119	Joe Mott#609	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#120	Dave McCloughan#798	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#121	Kelvin Pritchett#749	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#122	Danny Lockett#706	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#123	Alfred Williams#747	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#124	Sam Clancy#525	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#125	Ted Washington#754	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#126	Tom Tupa#629	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#127	Matt Bahr#53	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#128	John Johnson#782	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#129	Vinnie Clark#748	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#130	Dan Fike#477	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#131	Tim Irwin#218	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#132	Morris Lewis#792	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#133	Marv Cook#227	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#134	Marcus Turner#269	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#135	Derrick Thomas#19	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#136	GEORGE THORNTON#765	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#137	John Gesek#130	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#138	Howie Long#725Think About It	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#139	Matt Bahr#342	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#140	Mike Croel#733	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#141	Leonard Russell#743	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#142	Mike Jones#761	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#143	Ed King#758	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#144	Mike Baab#469	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#145	Jon Hand#527	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#146	Kevin Walker#466	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#147	John Alt#181	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#148	REGGIE BARRETT#787	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#149	Dan McGwire#745	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#150	Ricky Ervins#805	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#151	Chris Zorich#778	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#152	Joe Bugel#270	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#153	Al Toon#251	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#154	Mel Gray#403	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#155	Browning Nagle#763	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#156	John Rade#438	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#157	Tim McGee#115	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#158	Harvey Williams#750	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#159	Chris Gardocki#807	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#160	Herschel Walker#576	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#161	Jim Mora#243	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#162	Carl Lee#398	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#163	TIM BARNETT#806	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#164	Kevin Donnalley#808	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#165	Seth Joyner#257	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#166	Randal Hill#752	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#167	Derrick Walker#648	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#168	Art Shell#432	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#169	Mike Kenn#437	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#170	Eric Hill#623	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#171	John Brantley#705	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#172	Kent Hull#76	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#173	Sam Wyche#117	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#174	PAT LEAHY#607	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#175	Drew Hill#516	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#176	Wesley Carroll#771	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#177	CALVIN STEPHENS#785	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#178	Pro Set Gazette Official	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#179	Carl Lee#574	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#180	Joe Valerio#779	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#181	Rob Selby#804	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#182	Andre Rison#380	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#183	ROBERT WILSON#809	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#184	Jerome Henderson#770	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#185	Godfrey Myles#791	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#186	Pat Harlow#740	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#187	Chris Zorich#33	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#188	Bobby Wilson#746	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#189	Dan Crossman#708	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#190	Eric Swann#735	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#191	AARON CRAVER#789	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#192	Anthony Parker#707	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#193	John Flannery#773	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#194	Mike Dumas#757	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#195	Doug Thomas#780	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#196	SHANE CURRY#769	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#197	Alfred Williams#35	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#198	Eric Wilkerson#709	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#199	Don Matthews#21	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#200	Lamar Rogers#781	$0Raw	—	—	57.0