| #1 | Christian McCaffrey, Ed McCaffrey#18Gold | $600Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #2 | Jimmy Garoppolo, Tom Brady#29Red | $500PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 34.8 |
| #3 | Len Dawson, Patrick Mahomes II#20 | $345PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 51.0 |
| #4 | J.J. Watt, T.J. Watt#27Green | $136Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #5 | Cam Newton, Deshaun Watson#21 | $120PSA 10 | 4 | 0.0% | 44.8 |
| #6 | J.J. Watt, T.J. Watt#27Gold | $104Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #7 | Jimmy Garoppolo, Tom Brady#29Blue | $97PSA 10 | — | — | 42.8 |
| #8 | Chuck Foreman, Dalvin Cook#5Green | $70PSA 10 | — | — | 42.0 |
| #9 | Ben Roethlisberger, R. Joshua Dobbs#11Green | $70Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #10 | Jimmy Garoppolo, Tom Brady#29 | $65PSA 10 | — | — | 42.8 |
| #11 | Myles Garrett, Von Miller#12Blue | $61PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #12 | Christian McCaffrey, Ed McCaffrey#18 | $53PSA 10 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #13 | Alvin Kamara, Darren Sproles#9Blue | $50PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #14 | Myles Garrett, Von Miller#12 | $45PSA 10 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #15 | Alvin Kamara, Darren Sproles#9 | $44PSA 10 | — | — | 45.8 |
| #16 | J.J. Watt, T.J. Watt#27 | $42PSA 10 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #17 | J.J. Watt, T.J. Watt#27Blue | $39BGS 9.5 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #18 | Joe Mixon, Adrian Peterson#15Green | $37Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #19 | Joe Montana, Steve Young#30 | $37PSA 10 | — | — | 42.8 |
| #20 | Ezekiel Elliott, Emmitt Smith#28 | $35PSA 10 | — | — | 42.8 |
| #21 | Cam Newton, Deshaun Watson#21Blue | $35BGS 9.5 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #22 | Mike Evans, Chris Godwin#25Gold | $35Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #23 | Mike Evans, Chris Godwin#25 | $31PSA 10 | — | — | 42.8 |
| #24 | Jimmy Garoppolo, Tom Brady#29Gold | $31PSA 10 | — | — | 42.0 |
| #25 | Joe Montana, Steve Young#30Gold | $28Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #26 | Jim McMahon, Mitchell Trubisky#6Red | $25PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #27 | Eli Manning, Davis Webb#22Green | $24Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #28 | J.J. Watt, T.J. Watt#27Red | $21Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #29 | Fred Taylor, Leonard Fournette#16Gold | $20Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #30 | Cam Newton, Deshaun Watson#21Red | $20PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #31 | Ben Roethlisberger, R. Joshua Dobbs#11 | $18BGS 9.5 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #32 | Joe Montana, Steve Young#30Red | $16Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #33 | Kareem Hunt, Priest Holmes#3 | $16PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #34 | Eli Manning, Davis Webb#22Gold | $15Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #35 | Ezekiel Elliott, Emmitt Smith#28Red | $14Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #36 | Antonio Brown, JuJu Smith Schuster#17 | $13PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #37 | James Conner, Jerome Bettis#23 | $11PSA 10 | — | — | 39.8 |
| #38 | Chuck Foreman, Dalvin Cook#5 | $10PSA 10 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #39 | Myles Garrett, Von Miller#12Red | $10BGS 9.5 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #40 | Joe Montana, Steve Young#30Blue | $10Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #41 | Curtis Samuel, Steve Smith Sr.#14Gold | $9Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #42 | Mike Evans, Chris Godwin#25Red | $8Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #43 | Jim Kelly, Nathan Peterman#1Gold | $7Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #44 | Anquan Boldin, Kenny Golladay#26 | $6PSA 10 | — | — | 42.8 |
| #45 | Ben Roethlisberger, R. Joshua Dobbs#11Blue | $6Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #46 | Joe Mixon, Adrian Peterson#15 | $5BGS 9.5 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #47 | Jim Kelly, Nathan Peterman#1Red | $5Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #48 | DeShone Kizer, Joe Montana#7Blue | $5Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #49 | Eli Manning, Davis Webb#22Red | $5Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #50 | Chuck Foreman, Dalvin Cook#5Red | $5Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #51 | Ezekiel Elliott, Emmitt Smith#28Blue | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #52 | DeShone Kizer, Joe Montana#7 | $4PSA 10 | — | — | 45.8 |
| #53 | Mike Evans, Chris Godwin#25Blue | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #54 | Joe Mixon, Adrian Peterson#15Blue | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #55 | James Conner, Jerome Bettis#23Red | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #56 | Anquan Boldin, Kenny Golladay#26Blue | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #57 | DeShone Kizer, Joe Montana#7Red | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #58 | Eli Manning, Davis Webb#22Blue | $4Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #59 | Dez Bryant, Corey Davis#24Blue | $3Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #60 | Jim McMahon, Mitchell Trubisky#6 | $3Grade 8 | — | — | 48.0 |
| #61 | Evan Engram, Mark Bavaro#13Red | $3Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #62 | O.J. Howard, Ozzie Newsome#2Red | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #63 | Kareem Hunt, Priest Holmes#3Blue | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #64 | O.J. Howard, Ozzie Newsome#2Blue | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #65 | Mike Williams, Lance Alworth#8Red | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #66 | Jim McMahon, Mitchell Trubisky#6Blue | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #67 | Mike Williams, Lance Alworth#8Blue | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #68 | Andre Reed, Zay Jones#4Blue | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #69 | Curtis Samuel, Steve Smith Sr.#14Blue | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #70 | Evan Engram, Mark Bavaro#13 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #71 | DeShone Kizer, Joe Montana#7Green | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #72 | Eli Manning, Davis Webb#22 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #73 | Andre Reed, Zay Jones#4 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #74 | Curtis Samuel, Steve Smith Sr.#14 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #75 | D'Onta Foreman, Ricky Williams#19 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #76 | Dez Bryant, Corey Davis#24 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #77 | Mike Williams, Lance Alworth#8 | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #78 | Dez Bryant, Corey Davis#24Red | $2Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #79 | Evan Engram, Mark Bavaro#13Blue | $1Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #80 | O.J. Howard, Ozzie Newsome#2 | $1Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #81 | Jim Kelly, Nathan Peterman#1 | $1Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #82 | Jim Kelly, Nathan Peterman#1Blue | $1Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #83 | Fred Taylor, Leonard Fournette#16 | $1BGS 9.5 | — | — | 48.0 |