Andy Pettitte Foil #257 · Bowman (1995) | PopHunter

←Back to Baseball dashboard

Front

Andy Pettitte

Name: Andy Pettitte
Brand: Baseball
SKU: cmqerjm5f7dygz814iuprvusj

FoilRC

Bowman · #257 · 1995

eBaySearch Sold comps

Estimated Market Value · PSA 10

Estimate

Collector to unlockUpgrade

Where this card's market sits right now — modeled from its real sales and the movement of comparable markets.

PSA 10 $

$140

PSA 10 Pop

—

Gem Rate

—

30D Change

0.0%

Market data as of Jun 28, 2026

Opportunity

49.0

Collector

Collector to unlockUpgrade

Investor

Investor to unlockUpgrade

Speculation

Investor to unlockUpgrade

See pricing to unlock Collector, Investor & Speculation scores

Market

PSA10 / PSA9

14.74x

Active Listings

—

PSA10 Mkt Cap

—

PSA 10 Price

$140

30D PSA10

0.0%

90D PSA10

+7.7%

Raw Price

30D Raw

0.0%

90D Raw

-6.9%

Prices by Grade & Grader

Population Reports

⚠️ This population report appears to belong to a different print variant of this card (it conflicts with recorded PSA 10 sales). It is excluded from scoring and shown here for reference only.

PSA Population

0 total

PSA 10

PSA 9

PSA 8

PSA 7

PSA 6

PSA 5

PSA 4

PSA 3

PSA 10 Price

PSA 9 Price

PSA 10 Population

Total Population

Opportunity Score

Active Listings

Recent Sales

Date	Grade	Price	Platform	Title
Jun 22, 2026	Ungraded	$4	ebay	1995 Bowman Baseball Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil Rookie RC Card #257 #257
Jun 16, 2026	PSA 9	$10	ebay	1995 Bowman Foil #257 Andy Pettitte Yankees RC Rookie PSA 9 MINTT
Jun 13, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1995 Bowman - Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil #257 #257
May 30, 2026	PSA 10	$140	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Rookie Card RC Foil #273 PSA 10 GEM MINT Yankees NY #257
Apr 24, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman #257 Andy Pettitte FOIL NY YANKEES
Apr 23, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman Prime Prospect #257 Andy Pettitte Silver Foil #257
Apr 20, 2026	PSA 10	$74	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Foil PSA 10 New York Yankees #257
Mar 9, 2026	PSA 10	$158	ebay	1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE YANKEES PSA 10
Mar 4, 2026	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1995 Bowman Prime Prospect FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE New York Yankees #257
Feb 28, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	ANDY PETTITTE - 1995 Bowman "Foil" - #257 - Yankees - $1 Shipping - MINT #257
Feb 10, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil #257 New York Yankees #257
Feb 6, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	Andy Pettitte [Foil] #257 1995 Bowman #257
Feb 4, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman #257 Andy Pettitte FOIL ~ NY Yankees! #257
Feb 4, 2026	PSA 10	$200	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Foil PSA 10 New York Yankees #257
Jan 28, 2026	PSA 10	$170	ebay	ANDY PETTITTE 1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 PSA 10 RC POP 7 #257
Jan 25, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman # 257 Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil New York Yankees #257
Jan 21, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman # 257 Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil New York Yankees #257
Jan 11, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman Foil Andy Pettitte #257 #257
Dec 31, 2025	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1995 Bowman # 257 Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil New York Yankees o127 #257
Dec 15, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil #257 New York Yankees
Dec 13, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman Baseball Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Silver Foil , (HUCK’S) #257
Nov 24, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman # 257 Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil New York Yankees #257
Nov 12, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman # 257 Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Foil New York Yankees #257
Sep 25, 2025	Ungraded	$0	ebay	Andy Pettitte #257 - 1995 Bowman FOIL #257
Aug 30, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman #257 Andy Pettitte Foil Prime Prospect RC (8) CLOSE UP PICS #257
Aug 10, 2025	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte RC #257 Prime Prospect Silver Foil New York Yankees #257
Jul 5, 2025	Ungraded	$5	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect #257 Silver Foil (RC) Rookie Card #257
Jun 13, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman #257 Andy Pettitte Silver Foil #257
Jun 2, 2025	Ungraded	$3	ebay	Andy Pettitte 1995 Bowman #257 Foil Prospects New York Yankees #257
Feb 1, 2025	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman - Andy Pettitte - Prime Prospect - Silver Foil - #257 - NY Yankees #257
Jan 27, 2025	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE PRIME PROSPECT NEW YORK YANKEES
Jan 14, 2025	PSA 10	$50	ebay	ANDY PETTITTE - Prime Prospect / POP 6 /PSA 10 / (RC) 1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 #257
Sep 20, 2024	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman Baseball Andy Pettitte Prime Prospect Silver Foil #257
Jul 4, 2024	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1995 Bowman Prime Prospect Andy Pettitte Card Silver Foil 257 #257
Mar 6, 2024	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman Silver Foil Andy Pettitte New York Yankees #257 #257.
Jan 18, 2024	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1995 Bowman: #257 Andy Pettitte FOIL NM-MT OR BETTER GMCARDS #257
Dec 27, 2023	PSA 10	$34	ebay	1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE RC POP 6 PSA 10 #257
Jan 10, 2023	PSA 8	$1	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Foil #257 PSA 8 NM-MT #257
Aug 18, 2022	PSA 10	$51	ebay	1995 Bowman Andy Pettitte Foil Prime Prospect #257 PSA 10 Yankees A146
Aug 8, 2022	PSA 4	$2	ebay	1995 Bowman #257 Andy Pettitte FOIL - PSA 4
Aug 16, 2021	PSA 8	$5	ebay	1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE PSA 8 A3119202-886
Aug 16, 2021	PSA 8	$4	ebay	1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE PSA 8 A3119201-887
Aug 9, 2021	PSA 10	$56	ebay	1995 BOWMAN FOIL #257 ANDY PETTITTE POP 5 PSA 10 A3114112-797
Aug 1, 2021	PSA 8	$10	ebay	1995 Bowman Foil Andy Pettitte ROOKIE RC #257 PSA 8 NM-MT #257
May 4, 2021	PSA 7	$6	ebay	1995 Bowman #257 Andy Pettitte Foil PSA Graded 7 NM

Similar Opportunities

Same Player

Andy Pettitte #257 #257

1995 · Bowman Gold Foil

PopHunter surfaces potentially undervalued scarcity and relative value signals. This is not financial or investment advice. Always do your own research before purchasing graded cards.