Don Mattingly Base #109 · Fleer (1986) | PopHunter

←Back to Baseball dashboard

Front

Don Mattingly

Name: Don Mattingly
Brand: Baseball
SKU: cmqepkk71447wz814ejcnhc4j

Base💎 19.3% gem

Fleer · #109 · 1986

eBaySearch Sold comps

Estimated Market Value · PSA 10

Estimate

Collector to unlockUpgrade

Where this card's market sits right now — modeled from its real sales and the movement of comparable markets.

PSA 10 $

$679

PSA 10 Pop

Gem Rate

19.3%

30D Change

-0.1%

Market data as of Jul 4, 2026

Opportunity

52.8

Collector

Collector to unlockUpgrade

Investor

Investor to unlockUpgrade

Speculation

Investor to unlockUpgrade

See pricing to unlock Collector, Investor & Speculation scores

Market

PSA10 / PSA9

24.26x

Active Listings

—

PSA10 Mkt Cap

$57,719

PSA 10 Price

$679

30D PSA10

-0.1%

90D PSA10

+18.1%

Raw Price

30D Raw

+2.6%

90D Raw

-1.0%

Prices by Grade & Grader

Population Reports

PSA Population

440 total

PSA 10

PSA 9

151

PSA 8

132

PSA 7

PSA 6

PSA 5

PSA 4

PSA 3

PSA 10 Price

PSA 9 Price

PSA 10 Population

Total Population

Opportunity Score

Active Listings

Recent Sales

Date	Grade	Price	Platform	Title
Jun 28, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 #109
Jun 28, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly NM #109
Jun 27, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer - DON MATTINGLY #109 - New York Yankees - EX #109
Jun 27, 2026	PSA 8	$13	ebay	157894575 Don Mattingly 1986 Fleer #109 PSA 8 #109
Jun 24, 2026	PSA 8	$10	ebay	157894574 Don Mattingly 1986 Fleer #109 PSA 8 #109
Jun 16, 2026	Ungraded	$3	ebay	Don Mattingly 1986 Fleer #109 New York Yankees - Free Shipping #109
Jun 12, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer Baseball Card #109 DON MATTINGLY-NY Yankees #109
Jun 11, 2026	PSA 10	$695	ebay	1986 FLEER Don Mattingly PSA 10 Only One On eBay! #109
Jun 7, 2026	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly baseball card NM condition #109
Jun 6, 2026	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 #109
Jun 4, 2026	Ungraded	$5	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #109
May 29, 2026	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1986 Fleer Don Mattingly #109 New York Yankees #109
May 29, 2026	Ungraded	$3	ebay	1986 Fleer Baseball #109 - Don Mattingly - New York Yankees 86-884 #109
May 29, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly Excellent #109
May 28, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 B2 #109
May 27, 2026	PSA 8.5	$24	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 Don Mattingly PSA 8.5 #109
May 27, 2026	PSA 8	$20	ebay	1986 Fleer Don Mattingly #109 Graded PSA 8 Baseball Card #109
May 23, 2026	Ungraded	$4	ebay	1986 FLEER DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES #109 #109
May 21, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 New York Yankees Baseball Card #109
May 21, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	Fleer 1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Baseball Card #109
May 20, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer Set-Break #109 Don Mattingly NM-MT OR BETTER GMCARDS #109
May 19, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly #109
May 19, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES (FREE SHIPPING) #109
May 19, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly #109
May 19, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 #109
May 19, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 - Don Mattingly #109
May 19, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 #109
May 19, 2026	PSA 8	$18	ebay	1986 Fleer DON MATTINGLY #109 PSA 8 NM-MT New York Yankees HOF #109
May 17, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES (FREE SHIPPING) #109
May 13, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 - Don Mattingly #109
May 11, 2026	Ungraded	$0	ebay	1986 Fleer Baseball Card #109 Don Mattingly #246
May 11, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES (FREE SHIPPING) #109
May 11, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly #109
May 11, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 #109
May 8, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly #109
May 6, 2026	Ungraded	$5	ebay	Don Mattingly #109 1986 Fleer New York Yankees Baseball Card MLB NM #109
May 6, 2026	Grade 9	$34	ebay	Don Mattingly 1986 FLEER #109 - Beckett Graded 9 - FREE SHIPPING! (041526) #109
May 3, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly #109
May 2, 2026	Ungraded	$1	ebay	1986 Fleer Set Break #109 DON MATTINGLY NM-MT or BETTER H8020514 #109
May 1, 2026	Ungraded	$2	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly - Yankees
Apr 30, 2026	Ungraded	$7	ebay	1986 Fleer Set-Break #109 Don Mattingly NM-MT OR BETTER GMCARDS #109
Apr 28, 2026	SGC 9	$23	ebay	1986 Fleer #109 Don Mattingly New York Yankees SGC 9 #109
Apr 23, 2026	PSA 8	$8	ebay	1986 Fleer Don Mattingly #109 Yankees PSA 8
Apr 12, 2026	PSA 9	$30	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 Don Mattingly PSA 9 #109
Apr 2, 2026	PSA 8	$10	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 8
Mar 29, 2026	PSA 8	$10	ebay	1986 FLEER #109 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 8
Mar 23, 2026	PSA 10	$680	ebay	1986 FLEER Don Mattingly PSA 10 #109
Mar 23, 2026	SGC 8	$11	ebay	1986 Fleer DON MATTINGLY #109 SGC 8 (NM/MT) LOW POP. Yankees #109
Mar 22, 2026	PSA 8	$15	ebay	1986 Fleer Don Mattingly #109 PSA 8 NM-MT New York Yankees #109
Mar 20, 2026	PSA 7	$5	ebay	1986 Fleer - Don Mattingly #109 PSA 7 #109

Similar Opportunities

Same Player

Don Mattingly #133 #133

1985 · Fleer

PopHunter surfaces potentially undervalued scarcity and relative value signals. This is not financial or investment advice. Always do your own research before purchasing graded cards.