May 31, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle - #99 Don Mattingly #99 May 24, 2026 PSA 9 $20 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 May 20, 2026 SGC 9 $15 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly SGC 9 MINT #99 Apr 28, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle - Don Mattingly #99 Foil Gold Yankees #99 Apr 20, 2026 PSA 9 $20 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 Apr 3, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly Mar 31, 2026 PSA 7 $6 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY PSA 7 #99 Mar 25, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly #99 Mar 22, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle - Don Mattingly #99 #99 Mar 20, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Baseball Card #99 Mar 8, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Don Mattingly 1996 Pinnacle #99 MLB Baseball Card Yankees #99 Mar 3, 2026 PSA 10 $91 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY PSA 10 #99 Mar 2, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #99 Feb 26, 2026 PSA 10 $130 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 Feb 16, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle - Don Mattingly #99 Foil #99 Feb 6, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle - #99 Don Mattingly Feb 4, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly #99 Jan 14, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Don Mattingly #99 1996 Pinnacle New York Yankees #99 Jan 9, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly New York Yankees Baseball Card #99 Jan 3, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
Don Mattingly 1996 Pinnacle #99 NM-MT OR BETTER New York Yankees #99 Dec 26, 2025 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle Don Mattingly New York Yankees #99 Baseball Trading Card #99 Nov 26, 2025 Ungraded $0 e b a y
C55d #99 Don Mattingly, New York Yankees, 1996 pinnacle #99 Nov 10, 2025 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #99 Oct 29, 2025 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle Don Mattingly New York Yankees #99 #99 Sep 28, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
DON MATTINGLY - 1996 Pinnacle #99 **MINT** FREE SHIP & RETURN! #99 Sep 20, 2025 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly #99 Aug 2, 2025 Ungraded $3 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly New York Yankees #99 Jul 24, 2025 PSA 8 $25 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE DON MATTINGLY #99 PSA 8 YANKEES #9 May 30, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
Don Mattingly 1996 Pinnacle #99 MLB Baseball Card New York Yankees #99 Mar 29, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
DON MATTINGLY 1996 PINNACLE #99 FREE SHIPPING #99 Mar 23, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly Yankees Feb 27, 2025 Ungraded $3 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 Don Mattingly Yankees Baseball Card 1303F #99 Feb 26, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
DON MATTINGLY 1996 PINNACLE #99 FREE SHIPPING #99 Feb 15, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE - DON MATTINGLY YANKEES #99 #99 Feb 2, 2025 Ungraded $3 e b a y
DON MATTINGLY 1996 Pinnacle #99 C2 Jan 26, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
Don Mattingly 1996 Pinnacle Card 99 #99 Jan 18, 2025 PSA 9 $12 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 B4221487-817 Sep 22, 2024 PSA 9 $13 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9 B4094470-899 Feb 10, 2024 PSA 10 $100 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle #99 - Don Mattingly PSA 10 | Gem Mint | New York Yankees #99 Dec 29, 2022 PSA 8 $11 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY "HOF" PSA #8 NM-MT Sep 4, 2022 PSA 9 $34 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle Don Mattingly #99 PSA 9 MINT #99 Sep 3, 2022 PSA 9 $2 e b a y
1996 Pinnacle Don Mattingly #99 PSA 9 MINT #99 Jul 15, 2022 PSA 9 $16 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY PSA 9 Mar 9, 2022 PSA 10 $70 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE DON MATTINGLY #99 PSA 10 GEM MINT POP 19! #9 Apr 26, 2021 PSA 10 $37 e b a y
1996 PINNACLE #99 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10 A3057430-436 
Estimated market value — upgrade to Collector to unlock
