Jun 18, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Baseball Rookie Card - #196 - Gary Sheffield - Brewers #See Title Jun 5, 2026 PSA 9 $8 e b a y
Gary Sheffield 1989 Fleer Glossy #196 RC Rookie PSA 9 Low Pop 233 Only 30k Sets #196 May 31, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Glossy #196 May 23, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield Rookie RC #196 Brewers Apr 27, 2026 Grade 9 $1 e b a y
1989 Fleer GLOSSY Gary Sheffield #196 Beckett 9 #196 Apr 25, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) #196 Apr 6, 2026 Ungraded $20 e b a y
1989 Fleer GLOSSY- Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) #196 Mar 29, 2026 PSA 10 $180 e b a y
1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield Glossy Rookie RC #196 Brewers PSA 10 GEM MINT Mar 13, 2026 PSA 9 $30 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield RC PSA 9 MINT Brewers Yankees #196 Feb 9, 2026 PSA 9 $25 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) (PSA 9) #196 Feb 8, 2026 PSA 9 $6 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE #196 PSA 9 #196 Feb 6, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 (RC) Glossy (H6) #196 Feb 2, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD RC BREWERS NM-MT OR BETTER SET-BREAK #343 Jan 30, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1989 Fleer GLOSSY Gary Sheffield #196 RC #196 Jan 30, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) #196 Jan 27, 2026 Ungraded $8 e b a y
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Glossy Near Mint or Better HOF-10003733 Jan 21, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Glossy Excellent HOF-10003739 Jan 20, 2026 PSA 8 $9 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #196 Jan 15, 2026 PSA 8 $12 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield PSA 8 #196 Jan 7, 2026 Ungraded $5 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) #196 Jan 5, 2026 PSA 10 $211 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD RC BREWERS PSA 10 Jan 1, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Glossy Excellent HOF-10003740 Dec 4, 2025 Ungraded $8 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield RC Milwaukee Brewers #196 Dec 1, 2025 Ungraded $6 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) #196 Dec 1, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) #196 Nov 21, 2025 PSA 8 $7 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #196 Nov 18, 2025 Grade 8 $16 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD RC BREWERS BECKETT 8.5 NM-MT+ #196 Nov 5, 2025 PSA 10 $275 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY BLUE BACK GARY SHEFFIELD RC PSA 10 EXTREMLY RARE POP 54 #196 Oct 27, 2025 PSA 10 $205 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT, Scarce, Brewers #196 Oct 18, 2025 PSA 6 $5 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 6 #196 Oct 10, 2025 PSA 8 $6 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #196 Oct 1, 2025 PSA 9 $11 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield Brewers RC Rookie PSA 9 " MISLABEL " Sep 14, 2025 PSA 8 $11 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #196 Sep 4, 2025 Ungraded $10 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield RC Milwaukee Brewers #196 Aug 29, 2025 PSA 10 $203 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy - Gary Sheffield #196 Glossy (RC) PSA GEM MT 10 #196 Aug 29, 2025 PSA 9 $16 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD RC BREWERS PSA 9 Aug 5, 2025 PSA 9 $30 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield RC PSA 9 MINT #196 Jul 31, 2025 PSA 9 $20 e b a y
1989 Fleer GLOSSY #196 Gary Sheffield RC Rookie MINT PSA 9 BREWERS #196 Jul 28, 2025 Ungraded $6 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield RC #196 #196 Jul 20, 2025 PSA 9 $7 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE CARD RC #196 PSA 9 #196 Jul 9, 2025 PSA 9 $16 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield #196 PSA 9 MINT Rookie RC #196 Jun 16, 2025 Ungraded $8 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield RC Milwaukee Brewers #196 Jun 11, 2025 PSA 9 $20 e b a y
PSA 9 1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield #196 Rookie Mint!! #196 Jun 6, 2025 PSA 8 $9 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 8 #196 May 26, 2025 PSA 8 $1 e b a y
Gary Sheffield 1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Rookie, PSA 8 #196 May 21, 2025 PSA 10 $250 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield #196 Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT Brewers #196 May 21, 2025 PSA 10 $169 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD RC BREWERS PSA 10 May 18, 2025 PSA 9 $20 e b a y
1989 FLEER GLOSSY #196 GARY SHEFFIELD RC BREWERS PSA 9 Mar 29, 2025 Ungraded $1 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy Gary Sheffield #196 Rookie RC #196 Mar 14, 2025 Ungraded $8 e b a y
1989 Fleer Glossy #196 Gary Sheffield RC Milwaukee Brewers #196 
Estimated market value — upgrade to Collector to unlock
