Jun 28, 2026 Ungraded $32 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Mays Catch Makes Series History #464 #464 Jun 28, 2026 SGC 3 $73 e b a y
Topps 1959 Baseball Thrills #464 Willie Mays SGC 3 Mays' Catch Series #464 Jun 27, 2026 PSA 5 $162 e b a y
1959 TOPPS WILLIE MAYS #464 - CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY - PSA 5 Jun 26, 2026 Ungraded $40 e b a y
1959 Topps “Baseball Thrills” Willie Mays #464 The Catch Vg Creased #464 Jun 26, 2026 PSA 7 $316 e b a y
1959 Topps Set-Break #464 Mays' Catch Makes Series History PSA 7 NM #464 Jun 24, 2026 SGC 5 $135 e b a y
1959 Topps Willie Mays Catch #464 Mays' Catch Makes Series History SGC 5 EX #464 Jun 24, 2026 SGC 3 $63 e b a y
1959 TOPPS THRILLS BASEBALL #464 MAYS' CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY SGC 3 VG #464 Jun 23, 2026 Ungraded $45 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch Makes History #464 #464 Jun 23, 2026 PSA 5 $148 e b a y
1959 Topps #464 Willie Mays' Catch Makes Series History PSA 5 EX Jun 21, 2026 Ungraded $61 e b a y
1959 Topps - Baseball Thrills Willie Mays #464 Mays World Series Catch EX-MT 🔥 #464 Jun 21, 2026 Ungraded $58 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Mays' Catch Makes Series History 0n1i #464 Jun 20, 2026 Ungraded $56 e b a y
Willie Mays 1959 Topps #464 - Baseball Thrills, Mays' Catch Makes Series History #464 Jun 19, 2026 Ungraded $60 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball #464 Mays Catch Makes Series ... (Baseball Thrills) VG *h1 #464 Jun 18, 2026 PSA 3 $95 e b a y
1959 TOPPS #464 MAYS' CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY PSA 3 VG #464 Jun 18, 2026 SGC 3 $105 e b a y
1959 Topps - Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch #464 SGC 3 #464 Jun 18, 2026 PSA 2 $40 e b a y
1959 Topps Mays Catch Makes Series History #464 Willie Mays HOF. PSA 2(mc) #464 Jun 17, 2026 Ungraded $51 e b a y
1959 TOPPS BASEBALL#464 WILLIE MAYS BASEBALL THRILLS CATCH VG/EX #464 Jun 17, 2026 Ungraded $45 e b a y
1959 Topps - Baseball Thrills Willie Mays #464 Mays World Series Catch #464 Jun 17, 2026 PSA 1.5 $27 e b a y
1959 Topps - Mays Catch Makes Series History #464 Baseball Thrills PSA 1.5 #464 Jun 13, 2026 Ungraded $50 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch Makes Series History #464 VG #464 Jun 11, 2026 Ungraded $36 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch New York Giants #464 C05 #464 Jun 10, 2026 Ungraded $41 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Mays' Catch Makes Series History HOF #464 Jun 10, 2026 PSA 6 $220 e b a y
1959 Topps Willie Mays #464 Mays' Catch Makes Series History PSA 6 #464 Jun 9, 2026 Ungraded $60 e b a y
Willie Mays 1959 Topps #464 - Baseball Thrills, Mays' Catch Makes Series History #464 Jun 8, 2026 Ungraded $57 e b a y
1959 Topps #464 Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch Original Baseball Card EX-NM #464 Jun 8, 2026 Ungraded $35 e b a y
1959 Topps #464 Willie Mays' Catch Makes Series History EXCELLENT #464 Jun 7, 2026 Ungraded $50 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch Makes History #464 VG (crease) #464 Jun 7, 2026 PSA 3 $76 e b a y
1959 Topps Mays' Catch Makes Series History Baseball Card #464 PSA 3 VG #464 Jun 6, 2026 PSA 5 $145 e b a y
1959 Topps Mays Catch Makes Series History #464 PSA EX 5 #464 Jun 5, 2026 SGC 4 $82 e b a y
Topps 1959 #464 Mays' Catch Baseball Thrills Willie Mays SGC 4 Giants #464 Jun 5, 2026 PSA 3 $54 e b a y
1959 TOPPS #464 WILLIE MAYS / MAYS' CATCH MAKES HISTORY PSA 3 #464 Jun 4, 2026 Ungraded $51 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch Makes Series History #464 VG-VGEX #464 Jun 3, 2026 PSA 2 $43 e b a y
1959 Topps - Willie Mays' Catch Makes History (PSA 2) #464 Jun 1, 2026 Ungraded $72 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Mays' Catch Makes Series History HOF z7j #464 Jun 1, 2026 PSA 6 $168 e b a y
Willie Mays Giants 1959 Topps Baseball Thrills Card #464 Mays' Catch PSA 6 HOF #464 May 31, 2026 Ungraded $84 e b a y
1959 Topps - #464 Willie Mays - Baseball Thrills - World Series Catch - MINT #464 May 30, 2026 SGC 4.5 $115 e b a y
1959 TOPPS THRILLS BASEBALL #464 MAYS' CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY SGC 4.5 VG EX+ #464 May 29, 2026 SGC 4 $79 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills #464 Willie Mays Catch VG-EX SGC 4 May 28, 2026 Ungraded $50 e b a y
1959 TOPPS Baseball Card WILLIE MAYS #464 - MAY'S CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY #464 May 28, 2026 Ungraded $85 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills #464 May's Catch Makes Series History EX-MT #464 May 28, 2026 PSA 4 $115 e b a y
Willie Mays 1959 Topps Mays’ Catch Makes History #464 PSA 4 VG-EX HOF THRILL #464 May 27, 2026 SGC 4 $110 e b a y
1959 TOPPS THRILLS BASEBALL #464 MAYS' CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY SGC 4 VG EX A #464 May 25, 2026 Ungraded $38 e b a y
1959 Topps 464 Baseball Thrills Willie Mays Catch Makes History BH VINTAGE SALE #464 May 25, 2026 PSA 5 $116 e b a y
1959 TOPPS SERIES HISTORY #464 MAYS' CATCH MAKES PSA 5 #464 May 25, 2026 PSA 2.5 $65 e b a y
1959 Topps #464 Mays' Catch Makes Series History PSA 2.5 #464 May 24, 2026 PSA 4 $90 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball #464 MAYS CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY PSA 4 VG-EX Just Graded #464 May 23, 2026 SGC 8 $668 e b a y
WILLIE MAYS 1959 TOPPS #464 MAYS CATCH MAKES SERIES HISTORY SGC 8 CENTERED SHARP #464 May 23, 2026 PSA 7 $297 e b a y
1959 Topps #464 Willie Mays Catch Makes History PSA 7 NM Baseball Card Giants #464 May 22, 2026 Ungraded $50 e b a y
1959 TOPPS BASEBALL #464 MAYS CATCH WORLD SERIES HISTORY HOF NY GIANTS CENTERED #464 May 22, 2026 Ungraded $55 e b a y
1959 Topps Baseball Thrills (Mays Catch Makes Series History) #464 VG #464 
Estimated market value — upgrade to Collector to unlock
