| #1 | Mickey Mantle#135Gray Back | $183,912PSA 9 | 8,734 | — | 74.8 |
| #2 | Jackie Robinson#30Gray Back | $118,400PSA 9 | 2,788 | — | 71.3 |
| #3 | Roberto Clemente#33Gray Back | $88,450PSA 9 | 2,317 | — | 71.8 |
| #4 | Jackie Robinson#30White Back | $58,500PSA 9 | 5,988 | — | 73.3 |
| #5 | Sandy Koufax#79Gray Back | $48,054PSA 9 | 2,121 | — | 69.3 |
| #6 | Hank Aaron#31 | $42,000SGC 10 | 6,525 | — | 70.5 |
| #7 | Willie Mays#130Gray Back | $42,000PSA 9 | 6,199 | — | 73.8 |
| #8 | Ted Williams#5White Back | $35,750PSA 9 | 4,650 | — | 70.3 |
| #9 | Billy Martin#181 | $27,600PSA 10 | 1,844 | 0.0% | 74.8 |
| #10 | Roy Campanella#101Gray Back | $26,985PSA 9 | 3,507 | — | 73.3 |
| #11 | Ted Williams#5Gray Back | $22,200PSA 9 | 2,002 | — | 73.3 |
| #12 | Roberto Clemente#33White Back | $20,051PSA 9 | 5,338 | — | 76.8 |
| #13 | Sandy Koufax#79White Back | $16,450PSA 9 | 5,130 | — | 74.8 |
| #14 | William Harridge#1White Back | $15,000PSA 9 | 995 | — | 73.3 |
| #15 | William Harridge#1Gray Back | $15,000PSA 9 | 395 | — | 69.5 |
| #16 | Orioles Team#100With Date White Back | $13,420PSA 9 | 367 | — | 66.3 |
| #17 | Larry Doby#250 | $9,000PSA 9 | 1,290 | — | 73.8 |
| #18 | Minnie Minoso#125Gray Back | $8,235PSA 9 | 1,490 | — | 65.3 |
| #19 | Chuck Diering#19White Back | $8,100PSA 10 | 740 | 0.0% | 65.8 |
| #20 | Phil Rizzuto#113Gray Back | $7,320PSA 9 | 2,583 | — | 67.8 |
| #21 | Yogi Berra#110Gray Back | $6,979PSA 9 | 3,759 | — | 71.3 |
| #22 | Pee Wee Reese#260 | $6,710PSA 9 | 2,429 | — | 71.8 |
| #23 | Gil Hodges#145Gray Back | $6,405PSA 9 | 2,053 | — | 67.3 |
| #24 | Luis Aparicio#292 | $6,000PSA 9 | 3,386 | — | 75.3 |
| #25 | Harmon Killebrew#164Gray Back | $5,981PSA 9 | 3,292 | — | 69.8 |
| #26 | Dodgers Team#166Gray Back | $5,734PSA 9 | 1,881 | — | 64.3 |
| #27 | Duke Snider#150Gray Back | $5,524PSA 9 | 3,486 | — | 71.8 |
| #28 | Enos Slaughter#109Gray Back | $5,200PSA 9 | 1,346 | — | 71.8 |
| #29 | Ed Mathews#107Gray Back | $5,124PSA 9 | 2,779 | — | 68.8 |
| #30 | Al Kaline#20White Back | $4,676PSA 9 | 2,689 | — | 68.8 |
| #31 | Don Newcombe#235 | $4,647PSA 9 | 1,338 | — | 70.3 |
| #32 | Willie Mays#130White Back | $4,450Grade 8 | 777 | — | 59.8 |
| #33 | Ernie Banks#15Gray Back | $3,967Grade 8 | 1,672 | — | 55.8 |
| #34 | Braves Team#95White Back | $3,360PSA 9 | 394 | — | 75.3 |
| #35 | Yankees Team#251 | $3,154PSA 9 | 1,762 | — | 68.3 |
| #36 | Walter Alston#8Gray Back | $2,989PSA 9 | 446 | — | 63.5 |
| #37 | Ernie Banks#15White Back | $2,700Grade 8 | 3,412 | — | 56.8 |
| #38 | Monte Irvin#194 | $2,655PSA 9 | 1,167 | — | 71.3 |
| #39 | Hoyt Wilhelm#307 | $2,500PSA 9 | 1,471 | — | 70.3 |
| #40 | Orioles Team#100No Date White Back | $2,429PSA 9 | 305 | — | 70.0 |
| #41 | Tommy Carroll#139White Back | $2,402PSA 9 | 66 | — | 76.0 |
| #42 | Robin Roberts#180Gray Back | $2,280SGC 10 | 1,913 | — | 67.5 |
| #43 | Warren Spahn#10White Back | $2,157PSA 9 | 2,427 | — | 71.8 |
| #44 | Elston Howard#208 | $1,920PSA 9 | 1,480 | — | 69.3 |
| #45 | Johnny Podres#173Gray Back | $1,891PSA 9 | 1,073 | — | 65.3 |
| #46 | Frank House#32Gray Back | $1,777PSA 9 | — | — | 60.8 |
| #47 | Walter Alston#8White Back | $1,708PSA 9 | 1,017 | — | 67.3 |
| #48 | Jim Gilliam#280 | $1,708PSA 9 | 965 | — | 74.3 |
| #49 | Ed Roebuck#58White Back | $1,557PSA 9 | 705 | — | 62.8 |
| #50 | Richie Ashburn#120Gray Back | $1,525PSA 9 | 1,854 | — | 62.3 |
| #51 | George Kell#195 | $1,490PSA 9 | 1,014 | — | 67.8 |
| #52 | Bob Feller#200 | $1,452PSA 9 | 2,658 | — | 75.3 |
| #53 | Early Wynn#187 | $1,425PSA 9 | 1,181 | — | 74.8 |
| #54 | Carl Erskine#233 | $1,392PSA 9 | 1,107 | — | 68.8 |
| #55 | Don Zimmer#99White Back | $1,360PSA 9 | 935 | — | 71.8 |
| #56 | Bob Lemon#255 | $1,319PSA 9 | 1,139 | — | 74.3 |
| #57 | Nellie Fox#118Gray Back | $1,267PSA 9 | 1,774 | — | 65.8 |
| #58 | Bill Tremel#96Gray Back | $1,248PSA 9 | 188 | — | 61.5 |
| #59 | Al Kaline#20Gray Back | $1,246Grade 8 | 1,093 | — | 57.8 |
| #60 | Roger Craig#63Gray Back | $1,166PSA 9 | 326 | — | 62.0 |
| #61 | Bob Friend#221 | $1,148PSA 9 | 639 | — | 71.8 |
| #62 | Chuck Diering#19Gray Back | $1,136PSA 9 | 210 | — | 66.0 |
| #63 | Roger Craig#63White Back | $1,110PSA 9 | 851 | — | 72.3 |
| #64 | Curt Simmons#290 | $1,082PSA 9 | 613 | — | 71.8 |
| #65 | Whitey Ford#240 | $1,057Grade 8 | 2,565 | — | 59.3 |
| #66 | Mickey Mantle#135White Back | $1,013Raw | 861 | — | 66.0 |
| #67 | Cubs Team#11No Date Gray Back | $962Grade 8 | — | — | 51.0 |
| #68 | Ed Mathews#107White Back | $947Grade 8 | 285 | — | 55.8 |
| #69 | Bob Cerv#288 | $868PSA 9 | 787 | — | 69.8 |
| #70 | Dodgers Team#166White Back | $825Grade 8 | 117 | — | 53.5 |
| #71 | Joe Astroth#106Gray Back | $743PSA 9 | 603 | — | 62.0 |
| #72 | Joe Adcock#320 | $730PSA 9 | 803 | — | 70.3 |
| #73 | Joe Collins#21White Back | $659PSA 9 | 954 | — | 67.3 |
| #74 | Del Ennis#220 | $616PSA 9 | — | — | 63.5 |
| #75 | Ken Boyer#14White Back | $600PSA 9 | 896 | — | 66.8 |
| #76 | Orioles Team#100Gray Back | $591Grade 8 | — | — | 47.0 |
| #77 | Warren Giles#2Gray Back | $591Grade 8 | 324 | — | 49.0 |
| #78 | Warren Spahn#10Gray Back | $536Grade 8 | 1,028 | — | 53.8 |
| #79 | Don Larsen#332 | $463Grade 8 | 1,562 | — | 59.3 |
| #80 | Charley Neal#299 | $440PSA 9 | 872 | — | 63.8 |
| #81 | Frank Thomas#153White Back | $410Raw | 55 | — | 58.0 |
| #82 | Redlegs Team#90No Date White Back | $372Grade 8 | — | — | 48.5 |
| #83 | Mickey McDermott#340 | $360Grade 8 | 955 | — | 54.3 |
| #84 | Ted Kluszewski#25Gray Back | $360Grade 8 | 388 | — | 54.3 |
| #85 | Bob Hale#231 | $355PSA 9 | 501 | — | 66.8 |
| #86 | Laurin Pepper#108Gray Back | $330PSA 9 | 583 | — | 62.0 |
| #87 | Wayne Terwilliger#73Gray Back | $323PSA 9 | — | — | 59.3 |
| #88 | Erv Palica#206 | $276PSA 9 | 663 | — | 69.3 |
| #89 | Ted Kluszewski#25 | $263Grade 8 | — | — | 53.8 |
| #90 | Hank Aaron#31Gray Back | $260Raw | 54 | — | 68.5 |
| #91 | Rudy Minarcin#36White Back | $223Grade 8 | 473 | — | 47.0 |
| #92 | Roy Face#13Gray Back | $205Grade 8 | 204 | — | 50.0 |
| #93 | Sam Jones#259 | $189Grade 8 | 516 | — | 55.8 |
| #94 | Bob Miller#263 | $187Grade 8 | 461 | — | 51.3 |
| #95 | Vic Wertz#300 | $177Grade 8 | 652 | — | 48.8 |
| #96 | Jim Rivera#70Gray Back | $160Grade 8 | — | — | 41.8 |
| #97 | Joe Nuxall#218 | $156Grade 8 | — | — | 51.0 |
| #98 | Andy Pafko#312 | $147Grade 8 | 740 | — | 49.3 |
| #99 | Duke Maas#57Gray Back | $117Grade 8 | 238 | — | 47.5 |
| #100 | Arnold Portocarrero#53White Back | $115Grade 8 | 497 | — | 49.8 |
| #101 | Willie Miranda#103White Back | $101Grade 8 | 71 | — | 54.3 |
| #102 | Yogi Berra#110White Back | $90Raw | 231 | — | 63.8 |
| #103 | Bob Keegan#54Gray Back | $78Grade 8 | — | — | 48.5 |
| #104 | Roy Campanella#101White Back | $59Raw | 204 | — | 65.8 |
| #105 | Gil Hodges#145White Back | $55Raw | 67 | — | 62.3 |
| #106 | Duke Snider#150White Back | $34Raw | 2 | — | 60.8 |
| #107 | Enos Slaughter#109White Back | $31Raw | 68 | — | 62.3 |
| #108 | Carl Furillo#190 | $23Raw | 3 | 0.0% | 63.5 |
| #109 | Cubs Team#11Gray Back | $23Raw | 2 | — | 60.8 |
| #110 | Braves Team#95With Date White Back | $22Raw | 1 | 0.0% | 53.5 |
| #111 | Cubs Team#11White Back | $18Raw | 12 | — | 59.5 |
| #112 | Irv Noren#253 | $17Raw | 1 | — | 61.5 |
| #113 | Nationals Team#146White Back | $14Raw | 106 | — | 61.8 |
| #114 | Nationals Team#146Gray Back | $12Raw | 6 | — | 58.8 |
| #115 | Johnny Podres#173White Back | $12Raw | 1 | — | 48.0 |
| #116 | Vernon Law#252 | $12Raw | 3 | — | 58.5 |
| #117 | Phillies Team#72With Date White Back | $11Raw | 2 | — | 55.8 |
| #118 | Stu Miller#293 | $10Raw | 4 | — | 65.5 |
| #119 | Jim Piersall#143White Back | $10Raw | 1 | — | 55.5 |
| #120 | Jim Small#207 | $10Raw | 1 | — | 61.5 |
| #121 | Bob Miller#334 | $9Raw | 1 | — | 65.5 |
| #122 | Gene Baker#142White Back | $9Raw | 1 | — | 59.3 |
| #123 | Walt Dropo#238 | $9Raw | 3 | — | 62.0 |
| #124 | Jim Piersall#143Gray Back | $9Raw | 7 | — | 60.8 |
| #125 | Phillies Team#72Gray Back | $9Raw | 5 | — | 55.3 |
| #126 | Al Silvera#137White Back | $8Raw | 1 | — | 56.3 |
| #127 | Ned Garver#189 | $8Raw | 1 | — | 62.0 |
| #128 | Al Rosen#35White Back | $7Raw | 3 | — | 62.5 |
| #129 | Bob Skinner#297 | $7Raw | 2 | — | 63.5 |
| #130 | Warren Giles#2White Back | $7Raw | 9 | — | 62.5 |
| #131 | Frank Lary#191 | $7Raw | 4 | — | 61.5 |
| #132 | Russ Meyer#227 | $7Raw | 1 | — | 63.0 |
| #133 | Don Kaiser#124White Back | $7Raw | 74 | — | 60.3 |
| #134 | Elmer Valo#3White Back | $6Raw | 3 | — | 61.0 |
| #135 | Bob Buhl#244 | $6Raw | 2 | — | 61.0 |
| #136 | Andy Seminick#296 | $6Raw | 2 | — | 62.0 |
| #137 | Hal Smith#283 | $6Raw | 5 | 0.0% | 64.5 |
| #138 | Tommy Byrne#215 | $6Raw | 1 | — | 63.0 |
| #139 | Bob Lennon#104White Back | $6Raw | 1 | — | 57.3 |
| #140 | Harvey Haddix#77Gray Back | $6Raw | 2 | — | 57.3 |
| #141 | Hal Naragon#311 | $6Raw | 2 | — | 59.5 |
| #142 | Eddie Robinson#302 | $6Raw | 2 | — | 63.0 |
| #143 | Art Ditmar#258 | $6Raw | 1 | — | 65.5 |
| #144 | Clem Labine#295 | $6Raw | 2 | — | 61.5 |
| #145 | Tom Hurd#256 | $6Raw | 3 | — | 65.0 |
| #146 | Toby Atwell#232 | $5Raw | 5 | — | 64.0 |
| #147 | Don Hoak#335 | $5Raw | 3 | — | 65.5 |
| #148 | Bill Sarni#247 | $5Raw | 3 | 0.0% | 63.0 |
| #149 | Art Houtteman#281 | $5Raw | 1 | — | 61.0 |
| #150 | Hal Jeffcoat#289 | $5Raw | 6 | — | 61.5 |
| #151 | Bob Rush#214 | $5Raw | 3 | — | 61.5 |
| #152 | Frank Kellert#291 | $5Raw | 1 | — | 60.5 |
| #153 | Bill Tuttle#203 | $5Raw | 1 | — | 63.0 |
| #154 | Roy Sievers#75Gray Back | $5Raw | 1 | — | 55.5 |
| #155 | Ernie Johnson#294 | $5Raw | 3 | — | 62.0 |
| #156 | Jim Hearn#202 | $5Raw | 3 | — | 60.0 |
| #157 | Ike Delock#284 | $5Raw | 1 | — | 63.0 |
| #158 | Frank Sullivan#71White Back | $5Raw | 2 | — | 60.5 |
| #159 | Freddie Marsh#23Gray Back | $5Raw | 1 | — | 55.0 |
| #160 | Johnny Schmitz#298 | $5Raw | 2 | — | 61.5 |
| #161 | Duke Maas#57White Back | $4Raw | 2 | — | 58.5 |
| #162 | Alvin Dark#148Gray Back | $4Raw | 1 | — | 59.0 |
| #163 | Al Rosen#35Gray Back | $4Raw | 2 | — | 54.3 |
| #164 | Bob Speake#66Gray Back | $4Raw | 2 | — | 55.8 |
| #165 | Dick Donovan#18White Back | $4Raw | 1 | — | 61.0 |
| #166 | Dusty Rhodes#50White Back | $4Raw | 7 | — | 62.5 |
| #167 | Jim Finigan#22White Back | $4Raw | 2 | — | 61.0 |
| #168 | Luis Arroyo#64Gray Back | $4Raw | 1 | — | 57.3 |
| #169 | Karl Olson#322 | $4Raw | 1 | — | 63.5 |
| #170 | Jim Rivera#70White Back | $4Raw | 3 | — | 59.0 |
| #171 | Ernie Oravetz#51White Back | $4Raw | 6 | — | 61.0 |
| #172 | Carlos Paula#4White Back | $4Raw | 1 | — | 59.5 |
| #173 | Bill Wight#286 | $4Raw | 3 | — | 61.5 |
| #174 | Al Aber#317 | $4Raw | 1 | — | 62.0 |
| #175 | Carlos Paula#4Gray Back | $4Raw | 1 | — | 57.3 |
| #176 | Jim Busby#330 | $4Raw | 3 | — | 61.5 |
| #177 | Jack Meyer#269 | $4Raw | 3 | — | 63.5 |
| #178 | Jim Dyck#303 | $4Raw | 5 | — | 62.5 |
| #179 | Bob Nieman#267 | $4Raw | 2 | — | 65.5 |
| #180 | Ed Roebuck#58Gray Back | $4Raw | 2 | — | 57.8 |
| #181 | Freddie Marsh#23White Back | $4Raw | 4 | — | 63.0 |
| #182 | Bobby Adams#287 | $4Raw | 3 | — | 62.0 |
| #183 | Tom Brewer#34Gray Back | $4Raw | 2 | — | 57.8 |
| #184 | Max Surkont#209 | $4Raw | 1 | — | 61.5 |
| #185 | Dick Hall#331 | $4Raw | 4 | — | 60.0 |
| #186 | Art Swanson#204 | $4Raw | 1 | — | 59.5 |
| #187 | Don Liddle#325 | $4Raw | 2 | — | 58.0 |
| #188 | Johnny O'Brien#65White Back | $4Raw | 1 | — | 59.0 |
| #189 | Marv Grissom#301 | $3Raw | 4 | — | 61.5 |
| #190 | Elmer Valo#3Gray Back | $3Raw | 1 | — | 55.8 |
| #191 | Tom Gorman#246 | $3Raw | 2 | 0.0% | 61.5 |
| #192 | Bill Tremel#96White Back | $3Raw | 3 | — | 61.0 |
| #193 | Grady Hatton#26Gray Back | $3Raw | 3 | — | 60.8 |
| #194 | Rudy Minarcin#36Gray Back | $3Raw | 1 | — | 56.8 |
| #195 | Nelson Burbrink#27Gray Back | $3Raw | 1 | — | 55.8 |
| #196 | Bob Lennon#104Gray Back | $3Raw | 4 | — | 55.3 |
| #197 | Al Smith#105Gray Back | $3Raw | 5 | — | 59.0 |
| #198 | Frank Sullivan#71Gray Back | $3Raw | 1 | — | 55.3 |
| #199 | Al Silvera#137Gray Back | $3Raw | 2 | — | 59.0 |
| #200 | Ernie Oravetz#51Gray Back | $3Raw | 2 | — | 57.3 |
| #201 | Jim Finigan#22Gray Back | $2Raw | 1 | — | 53.5 |
| #202 | Ron Negray#7Gray Back | $2Raw | 2 | — | 55.3 |