| #1 |  Mickey Mantle Hits: Longest Homer#422 | $6,405PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 50.5 |
| #2 |  Bobby Richardson: Sets Series Mark#415 | $1,055BGS BL | 2 | 0.0% | 42.3 |
| #3 |  Dickey Chosen All Star Catcher#434 | $1,045BGS BL | 2 | -0.7% | 42.8 |
| #4 |  Runnels Makes 9: Hits in Twin Bill#407 | $975BGS BL | 3 | 0.0% | 40.8 |
| #5 |  Gentile Powers: Birds Into 1st#401 | $910BGS BL | 1 | 0.0% | 38.3 |
| #6 |  Don Cardwell of Cubs Pitches#410 | $720BGS BL | 1 | +0.1% | 41.3 |
| #7 |  Indians' Woodie Held Slugs 2 Homers#405 | $260PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 42.8 |
| #8 |  Robinson Saves Dodgers for#428 | $197PSA 9 | — | — | 51.0 |
| #9 |  Snodgrass Muffs: A Fly Ball#454 | $168PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 45.8 |
| #10 |  Cy Young Honored#448 | $150PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 57.3 |
| #11 |  Homer By Yogi Berra: Puts Yanks in 1st Place#453 | $119BGS 9.5 | 5 | — | 46.5 |
| #12 | DiMag Comes Thru#467 | $108BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #13 | Stan Musial Hits: 5 Homers in 1 Day#421 | $100BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #14 | Kaline Hits 3: Homers, 2 in Same Inning#465 | $93BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #15 | Dodgers Take Series: From Sox in Six#431 | $90PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 56.0 |
| #16 | Bean Ball Ends: Career of Mickey Cochrane#419 | $80BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #17 | Hubbell Strikes: Out 5 AL Stars#479 | $76BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #18 | Sal Maglie Pitches: No Hit Game#470 | $73BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #19 | Banks Belts 47: Homers Earns MVP Award#420 | $71BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #20 | Hodges Hits 4 Home: Runs in Nite Game#441 | $66BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #21 | Mazeroski's Homer: Wins Series for Bucs#403 | $66BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #22 | Al Votes to Expand: To 10 Teams#414 | $66BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #23 | Bob Feller Hurls: 3rd No Hitter of Career#460 | $64BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #24 | Thomson's Homer: Sinks Dodgers#480 | $63BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #25 | Johnson Pitches 56: Scoreless Innings#440 | $63BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #26 | Yanks Champs Again!#461 | $63BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #27 | Larsen Hurls: Perfect World Series GM#418 | $61BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #28 | Warren Spahn Beats: Yanks in World Series#463 | $59BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #29 | Killebrew Starts: Spring Training#449 | $55BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #30 | Reese Honored As: Greatest Dodgers S. S.#437 | $54BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #31 | Turley Hurls Yanks: To Championship#430 | $54BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #32 | Early Wynn Victory: Crushes Yanks#471 | $52BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #33 | Campy Most: Valuable Player#429 | $52BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #34 | Harvey Kuenn Takes: AL Batting Title#459 | $51BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #35 | Owen Drops 3rd: Strike#475 | $50BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #36 | Rizzuto's 2 Runs: Save 1st Place#445 | $50BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #37 | Red Schoendienst: Key Player in Braves#425 | $48BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #38 | Erskine Sets Strike: Out Record in W. S.#469 | $46BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #39 | T. Kluszewski Stars: In 1st Series Game Win#457 | $45BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #40 |  Mantle Hits Longest: Homer at Stadium#450 | $44Raw | 8 | — | 53.0 |
| #41 | Podres Pitching: Wins Series#474 | $43BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #42 | Camilo Pascual Strikes Out 15 Bosox#411 | $41PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 56.0 |
| #43 |  Babe Ruth: Hits 60th Home Run#447 | $41Raw | 13 | — | 55.8 |
| #44 |  Umpires Clear: White Sox Bench#436 | $40PSA 9 | — | — | 51.0 |
| #45 | Adcock Gets Four: Homers, Double#433 | $39BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #46 | Burdette Beats Yank: In 3 Series Game#435 | $35BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #47 | Furillo Hero in 3rd: World Series Game#432 | $34BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #48 | Groat, NL Bat King: Named Loop's MVP#413 | $34BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #49 |  Babe Hits 3 Homers: In A Series Game#455 | $33Raw | 10 | — | 55.8 |
| #50 |  Willie Mays Makes: Greatest Catch#427 | $32Raw | 11 | — | 56.8 |
| #51 | Bob Allison Named: AL Rookie of the Year#466 | $30BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #52 | Dick Stuart Hits 3: Homers, Single#409 | $30BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #53 |  Midget Pinch Hits: For St. Louis Browns#426 | $30Raw | 4 | — | 53.0 |
| #54 | Colavito Hits Four: Homers in One Game#468 | $30Grade 8 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #55 |  Aaron's Bat Beats: Yankees in Series#462 | $30Raw | 8 | 0.0% | 58.8 |
| #56 | Vern Law Winner of: Cy Young Award#406 | $27BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #57 | New York Wins 26: Straight Games#456 | $27Grade 8 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #58 |  Ted Williams Hits: .406 for Season#439 | $25Raw | 8 | — | 59.3 |
| #59 | Sievers Captures: Home Run Title#423 | $24BGS 9.5 | — | — | 56.0 |
| #60 |  Joe DiMaggio Hits: In 56 Straight Games#438 | $23Raw | 6 | — | 56.8 |
| #61 |  Gehrig Consecutive: Game Record Ends#424 | $22Raw | 8 | — | 55.5 |
| #62 |  Willie Mays' 3: Triples Paces Giants'#404 | $22Raw | 11 | 0.0% | 53.0 |
| #63 |  Maris Nips Mantle: For AL MVP Award#416 | $20Raw | 7 | 0.0% | 58.0 |
| #64 |  Ted Williams Hero: Of All Star Game#452 | $20Raw | 7 | — | 59.5 |
| #65 |  Warren Spahn Hurls No Hitter#402 | $12Raw | 3 | — | 52.0 |
| #66 |  Mathewson Pitches 3: World Series Shutouts#477 | $10Raw | 6 | — | 52.5 |
| #67 |  Ty Cobb Named Best: Player of All Time#443 | $10Raw | 6 | — | 55.3 |
| #68 |  Merkle Pulls Boner#417 | $9Raw | 2 | — | 56.0 |
| #69 |  Dizzy and Daffy: Dean Win Series#476 | $7Raw | 4 | 0.0% | 48.0 |
| #70 |  Greenberg Returns: To Tigers From Army#442 | $7Raw | 5 | — | 54.5 |
| #71 |  Braves' Lew Burdette Wins No Hitter#408 | $7Raw | 3 | — | 58.8 |
| #72 |  Ott Walks 5 Times: In A Single Game#458 | $6Raw | 2 | 0.0% | 49.5 |
| #73 |  Haddix Pitches: 12 Perfect Innings#478 | $6Raw | 2 | — | 49.0 |
| #74 |  Braves Take Pennant#451 | $6Raw | 3 | 0.0% | 57.0 |
| #75 |  Pickoff Ends Series#473 | $6Raw | 3 | — | 48.5 |
| #76 |  Tigers Beat Out: Senators for Pennant#446 | $5Raw | 1 | 0.0% | 51.0 |
| #77 |  Robin Roberts Wins: 28 Games#444 | $5Raw | 2 | — | 54.5 |
| #78 |  Ump's Wrong Call: Helps Dodgers#464 | $4Raw | 1 | — | 52.0 |
| #79 |  Nellie Fox American: League's MVP#472 | $3Raw | 3 | 0.0% | 49.0 |