1996 Collector's Choice Card Prices & Most Valuable Cards — Baseball | PopHunter

1996 Collector's Choice

257 cards · top card $1,331 (Derek Jeter)

Ranked by value — top graded price, falling back to raw. Open in the full scanner →

257 cards

Rank	Card	Top grade	Total pop	30D	Opportunity?
#1	Derek Jeter#231Gold Signature	$1,331PSA 10	32	-0.4%	43.8
#2	Ken Griffey Jr.#310Gold Signature	$1,030PSA 10	28	0.0%	43.3
#3	Barry Bonds#300Gold Signature	$500PSA 10	2	0.0%	64.8
#4	Don Mattingly#237Silver Signature	$499PSA 10	1	0.0%	54.3
#5	Ozzie Smith#756Gold Signature	$495PSA 9	1	—	73.3
#6	Mark McGwire#640Gold Signature	$219PSA 10	2	0.0%	54.8
#7	Rickey Henderson#240Gold Signature	$200PSA 10	3	0.0%	53.8
#8	Ozzie Smith#104Silver Signature	$175PSA 10	—	0.0%	43.8
#9	Jorge Posada#636Gold Signature	$140PSA 10	3	0.0%	57.8
#10	New York Mets Checklist#397	$125Raw	—	—	56.0
#11	Don Mattingly#100Gold Signature	$106PSA 10	11	0.0%	40.3
#12	Rickey Henderson#240Silver Signature	$94PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#13	Ozzie Smith#280Gold Signature	$84BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#14	Frank Thomas#759Gold Signature	$79BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#15	Mariano Rivera#19	$79PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#16	Hideo Nomo#180	$72PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#17	Don Mattingly#100Silver Signature	$70PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#18	Jorge Posada#636	$64PSA 10	—	—	48.8
#19	Don Mattingly#237Gold Signature	$61BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#20	Deion sanders#306	$60PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#21	Billy Wagner#425	$57PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#22	Alex Rodriguez#316Gold Signature	$51BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#23	Kirby Puckett#200Silver Signature	$47PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#24	Bob Abreu#450	$46PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#25	Greg Maddux, Mike Mussina#6Silver Signature	$45PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#26	Hideo Nomo#332	$41PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#27	Babe Ruth#500	$40PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#28	Edgar Renteria#446	$38PSA 10	—	—	51.8
#29	Babe Ruth#500Gold Signature	$36BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#30	Ken Griffey Jr.#415	$36PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#31	Raul Ibanez#431	$35PSA 10	—	—	48.8
#32	Tony Gwynn#408	$35PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#33	Honus Wagner#504	$35PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#34	Derek Jeter#231	$35PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#35	Hideo Nomo#705	$34PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#36	Roger Clemens#101Silver Signature	$33PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#37	Will Clark#320Gold Signature	$31Grade 8	—	—	53.8
#38	Mark Grace#80	$30PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#39	Cal Ripken Jr.#1	$30PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#40	Edgar Martinez, Tony Gwynn#2Silver Signature	$30PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#41	Ozzie Smith#104Gold Signature	$30Raw	—	—	56.0
#42	Paul Molitor#414Gold Signature	$28Raw	—	—	56.0
#43	Kirby Puckett#200Gold Signature	$28Grade 8	—	—	56.0
#44	Sammy Sosa#490	$27PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#45	Will Clark#320	$27PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#46	Ken Griffey Jr.#415Gold Signature	$26BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#47	Tony Gwynn#290Gold Signature	$26Raw	—	—	56.0
#48	Ty Cobb#501	$25PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#49	Andre Dawson#150Silver Signature	$25PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#50	Cal Ripken Jr.#1Gold Signature	$24Raw	—	—	56.0
#51	Ryne Sandberg#495Gold Signature	$24Raw	—	—	56.0
#52	Frank Thomas#90Gold Signature	$23Raw	—	—	56.0
#53	A. Belle, E. Murray#364Team Checklist	$22PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#54	Tony Gwynn#290	$22PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#55	Tony Gwynn#760	$21PSA 10	—	—	53.8
#56	Paul Molitor#355	$21PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#57	Ivan Rodriguez#345	$20PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#58	Hideo Nomo#705Gold Signature	$20Raw	—	—	56.0
#59	Randy Johnson#365	$19PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#60	Sammy Sosa#106	$19PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#61	Craig Biggio#274	$19PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#62	Hideo Nomo#270	$18PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#63	Cal Ripken Jr.#362	$17PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#64	Harold Baines#55Silver Signature	$16Raw	—	—	56.0
#65	Roberto Alomar#339	$15PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#66	Joe Carter#350	$15PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#67	Manny Ramirez#329	$15PSA 10	—	—	56.0
#68	Mike Piazza#272Gold Signature	$13Raw	—	—	56.0
#69	Jose Canseco#475Silver Signature	$13Raw	—	—	56.0
#70	Mike Piazza#406Gold Signature	$13Raw	—	—	56.0
#71	Chipper Jones#42Gold Signature	$13Raw	—	—	56.0
#72	Barry Bonds#108Gold Signature	$11BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#73	Mariano Rivera#19Gold Signature	$10Raw	—	—	56.0
#74	Mike Cameron#507Gold Signature	$10Raw	—	—	56.0
#75	Rex Hudler#484Silver Signature	$9Raw	—	—	56.0
#76	Chipper Jones#42Silver Signature	$9BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#77	Todd Greene#664Silver Signature	$9Raw	—	—	57.0
#78	Jim Thome#120	$8PSA 10	—	—	47.8
#79	Eric Owens#519Silver Signature	$8Raw	—	—	56.0
#80	12 Player Trade, Caminiti Gold Signature#358Caminiti Gold Signature	$7Raw	—	—	56.0
#81	Steve Finley#696Gold Signature	$7BGS 9.5	—	—	56.0
#82	Jim Thome#392	$7PSA 10	—	—	50.8
#83	Chad Ogea#524Gold Signature	$6Raw	—	—	56.0
#84	Randy Johnson#365Gold Signature	$6Raw	—	—	56.0
#85	Cecil Fielder#422Gold Signature	$6Raw	—	—	56.0
#86	Rex Hudler#484	$6Raw	—	—	56.0
#87	Paul O'Neill#635Gold Signature	$5Raw	—	—	56.0
#88	Roger Clemens#60Gold Signature	$5Raw	—	—	56.0
#89	Tom Candiotti#179Silver Signature	$5Raw	—	—	56.0
#90	Latroy Hawkins#659Gold Signature	$5Raw	—	—	56.0
#91	Livan Hernandez#432Silver Signature	$4Raw	—	—	57.0
#92	Ivan Rodriguez#345Gold Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#93	Andy Pettitte#234Gold Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#94	David Cone#235Gold Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#95	Vinny Castilla#136Silver Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#96	Darryl Kile#564Silver Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#97	Wade Boggs#230Silver Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#98	Cecil Fielder#103Gold Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#99	Bret Boone#515Gold Signature	$4Raw	—	—	56.0
#100	Kirk Gibson#142Silver Signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#101	Jim Thome#120Silver Signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#102	David Bell#656Silver Signature	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#103	Tim Raines#95Silver Signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#104	Rafael Orellano#442	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#105	Rondell White#215gold signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#106	Jay Canizaro#448	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#107	Robert Smith#441	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#108	Jimmy Haynes#22Rookie Class	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#109	Robert Person#39Rookie Class	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#110	Tim Bogar#619Silver Signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#111	Jeff Suppan#428	$3Raw	—	—	57.0
#112	Sammy Sosa#106Gold Signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#113	Jeff Bagwell#160Silver Signature	$3Raw	—	—	56.0
#114	Rick Helling#323Gold Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#115	Jeff Bagwell#160Gold Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#116	John Olerud#750Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#117	Joe Randa#577	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#118	Cal Ripken Jr.#362Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#119	Jesus Tavarez#26Rookie Class	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#120	Ramon Martinez#186Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#121	Garret Anderson#69Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#122	Rey Ordonez#429Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#123	Cal Ripken Jr.#362Gold Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#124	Barry Larkin#520Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#125	Barry Larkin#401Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#126	Mike Devereaux#379NL Championship Series	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#127	Tom Gordon#169	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#128	Jay Powell#559	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#129	Jay Buhner#383AL Championship Series	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#130	Fernando Vina#197Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#131	Bill Swift#535	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#132	David Nied#134Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#133	Paul Molitor#355Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#134	karim garcia#35	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#135	Doug Henry#627	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#136	Frank Thomas#90Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#137	Jose Oliva#689Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#138	Barry Bonds#108Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#139	Alan Trammell#145Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#140	Mike Sweeney#438	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#141	Johnny Damon#411Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#142	Benito Santiago#669Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#143	John Kruk#98Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#144	Scott Klingenbeck#203	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#145	Randy Johnson#365Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#146	Todd Greene#664	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#147	Tim salmon#75	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#148	Todd Greene#440	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#149	Mark Carreon#302Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#150	Robby Thompson (Gold Signature)#308	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#151	Rod Beck#715	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#152	Mark Langston#73	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#153	Frank Thomas#105Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#154	LaTroy Hawkins#659	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#155	Tom Henke#285	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#156	Ivan Rodriguez#345Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#157	Marquis Grissom#41Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#158	Jon Nunnally#657	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#159	Zane Smith#63	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#160	John Smiley#522	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#161	John Vander Wal#133	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#162	Juan Castro#21	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#163	John Smoltz#49Gold Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#164	Shawn Estes#722Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#165	Jose Mesa#271Fantasy Team	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#166	Joey Cora#312	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#167	David Cone#235	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#168	Babe Ruth#500Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#169	Quinton McCracken#661Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#170	Mendy Lopez#427	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#171	Matt Lawton#34Rookie Class	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#172	Tim Unroe#662	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#173	Jermaine Dye#437	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#174	Ray Lankford#690Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#175	Dave Clark#677	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#176	robert eenhoorn#330	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#177	Sergio Nunez#436	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#178	Jay Buhner#730	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#179	Tim Scott#609	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#180	Benji Gil#322	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#181	Johnny Damon#650	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#182	Jose Rijo#113	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#183	Trey Beamon#435	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#184	Steve Reed#539	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#185	Joe Oliver#194	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#186	Todd Zeile#81	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#187	Jim Abbott#78	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#188	Mark Acre#638	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#189	Luis Sojo#728	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#190	Rey Ordonez#429	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#191	Jeff Ware#752	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#192	Brian Maxcy#143	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#193	Gary Sheffield#560Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#194	Quinton McCracken#661	$2Raw	—	—	57.0
#195	Jay Bell#675	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#196	Jeff King#258	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#197	Jeff Ware#663	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#198	Lyle Mouton#17Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#199	Jeff Kent#225	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#200	Freddy Garcia#261Silver Signatures	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#201	Dan Wilson#319Silver Signature	$2Raw	—	—	56.0
#202	Robert Smith#441silver signature	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#203	Matt Karchner#509	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#204	Fred McGriff#45Silver Signature	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#205	Jeff Manto#58Silver Signature	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#206	Jody Reed#298	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#207	Mo vaughn#273	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#208	Ron Gant#110	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#209	Steve Parris#267	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#210	John Kruk#98	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#211	Livan Hernandez#432	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#212	Ron Coomer#602	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#213	Curtis Goodwin#50	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#214	Mo vaughn#706	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#215	Ernie Young#666	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#216	Greg Zaun#51	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#217	Edwin Hurtado#16Rookie Class	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#218	Chan Ho Park#29Rookie Class	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#219	Al Martin#682	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#220	Jeff Manto#58	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#221	Craig Biggio#159Silver Signature	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#222	George Arias#426	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#223	Sammy Sosa#277	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#224	Bob Wolcott#23	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#225	Jon Lieber#262	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#226	Ray Durham#92	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#227	Charles Johnson#155All Rookie	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#228	Devon White#351	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#229	Ron Gant#711	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#230	Allen Battle#283	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#231	Melvin Bunch#168	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#232	Alex Fernandez#93	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#233	Todd Hollandsworth#182Silver Signature	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#234	Ron Gant#110Gold Signature	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#235	Larry Thomas#512Silver Signature	$1Raw	—	—	56.0
#236	Roger Cedeno#12Rookie Class	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#237	Orlando Palmeiro#37	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#238	Richard Hidalgo#439	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#239	Brooks Kieschnick#430	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#240	Osvaldo Fernandez#424	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#241	Chan Ho Park#658	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#242	David Bell#656	$1Raw	—	—	57.0
#243	Ruben Rivera#20Rookie Class	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#244	Dustin Hermanson#651	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#245	Chad Fonville#655	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#246	Wilton Guerrero#443	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#247	Steve Cox#434	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#248	Osvaldo Fernandez#424Rookie Class	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#249	Kevin Jordan#33Rookie Class	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#250	Troy Percival#72All Rookie	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#251	Jamie Brewington#660	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#252	Andrew Lorraine#665	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#253	Joe Randa#652	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#254	Shannon Stewart#433	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#255	Alan Benes#654	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#256	Enrique Wilson#449	$0Raw	—	—	57.0
#257	Brian Hunter#161	$0Raw	—	—	57.0