| #1 | Max Scherzer#173Photographer's Proof Gold Autograph | $3,500BGS 9.5 | — | — | 49.3 |
| #2 | Max Scherzer#140Photographer's Proof Gold | $2,750Grade 8 | — | — | 38.8 |
| #3 | Clayton Kershaw#176Photographer's Proof Gold Autograph | $1,710PSA 9 | — | — | 53.5 |
| #4 | Clayton Kershaw#176Autograph | $1,600PSA 10 | 4 | 0.0% | 63.0 |
| #5 | Clayton Kershaw#176Photographer's Proof Blue Autograph | $1,409PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 54.0 |
| #6 | Clayton Kershaw#107Throwing Fastball Photographer's Proof Gold | $1,000Raw | — | — | 48.0 |
| #7 | Clayton Kershaw#1071st Day Issue | $500PSA 10 | 3 | 0.0% | 57.5 |
| #8 | Clayton Kershaw#107Portrait Photographer's Proof Blue | $450PSA 9 | — | — | 49.0 |
| #9 | Max Scherzer#173Autograph | $437PSA 9 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #10 | Clayton Kershaw#107Throwing Fastball 1st Day Issue | $400PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 45.3 |
| #11 | Clayton Kershaw#107 | $369PSA 10 | 18 | 0.0% | 70.0 |
| #12 | Joey Votto#1121st Day Issue | $181PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 43.3 |
| #13 | Max Scherzer#140First Day Issue | $160PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 46.7 |
| #14 | Max Scherzer#140First Day Issue Retail | $159PSA 10 | 4 | 0.0% | 54.8 |
| #15 | Clayton Kershaw#1071st Day Issue Unnumbered | $150BGS 9.5 | — | — | 54.0 |
| #16 | Nick Adenhart#164Autograph | $148PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 51.5 |
| #17 | Evan Longoria#169Autograph | $130PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 53.2 |
| #18 | Max Scherzer#140 | $124PSA 10 | 7 | 0.0% | 62.8 |
| #19 | Clayton Kershaw#107Throwing Fastball | $114BGS 9.5 | — | — | 46.5 |
| #20 | Clayton Kershaw#107Throwing Fastball 1st Day Issue Retail | $111BGS 9.5 | 4 | — | 54.0 |
| #21 | Johnny Cueto#158Autograph | $107PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 48.5 |
| #22 | Joey Votto#112Photographer's Proof Gold | $105Grade 8 | — | — | 39.5 |
| #23 | Ty Cobb#931st Day Issue | $90PSA 10 | — | — | 47.8 |
| #24 | Derek Jeter#591st Day Issue | $85BGS 9.5 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #25 | Pedro Martinez#89 | $83BGS 9.5 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #26 | Ken Griffey Jr.#35Photographer's Proof Blue | $76BGS 9.5 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #27 | Albert Pujols#54First Day Issue | $66PSA 10 | — | — | 47.8 |
| #28 | Joey Votto#112Photographer's Proof Blue | $61Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #29 | Ted Williams#99First Day Issue | $59PSA 10 | — | — | 47.8 |
| #30 | Joey Votto#112 | $59PSA 10 | — | — | 47.8 |
| #31 | Ken Griffey Jr.#35 | $56PSA 10 | — | — | 47.8 |
| #32 | Roberto Clemente#98 | $54PSA 10 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #33 | Justin Verlander#781st Day Issue | $53PSA 10 | — | — | 47.8 |
| #34 | Justin Masterson#162 | $52PSA 10 | — | — | 48.8 |
| #35 | Ken Griffey Jr.#351st Day Issue | $52BGS 9.5 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #36 | Ichiro#511st Day Issue | $51PSA 10 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #37 | Max Scherzer#173Photographer's Proof Blue Autograph | $51Grade 8 | — | — | 43.0 |
| #38 | Mickey Mantle#92 | $50PSA 10 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #39 | Jackie Robinson#91 | $44PSA 10 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #40 | Johnny Cueto#116 | $43PSA 10 | — | — | 48.8 |
| #41 | Nolan Ryan#97 | $42PSA 10 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #42 | Honus Wagner#95 | $41PSA 10 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #43 | Derek Jeter#59 | $36PSA 10 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #44 | Roberto Clemente#981st Day Issue | $31BGS 9.5 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #45 | Evan Longoria#169 | $30Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #46 | Nick Adenhart#164 | $30Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #47 | Mickey Mantle#92First Day Issue | $30BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #48 | Kosuke Fukudome#132First Day Issue | $25PSA 10 | — | — | 45.8 |
| #49 | Nolan Ryan#97Photographer's Proof Gold | $25Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #50 | Ken Griffey Jr.#35Photographer's Proof Gold | $25Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #51 | Johnny Cueto#158 | $20Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #52 | Evan Longoria#1081st Day Issue | $20PSA 10 | — | — | 54.0 |
| #53 | Babe Ruth#96 | $18Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #54 | Chipper Jones#83Photographer's Proof Gold | $16Grade 8 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #55 | Albert Pujols#54 | $15Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #56 | Nolan Ryan#97First Day Issue | $14Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #57 | Chipper Jones#831st Day Issue | $14Grade 8 | — | — | 50.8 |
| #58 | Derek Jeter#59Photographer's Proof Gold | $13Grade 8 | — | — | 47.0 |
| #59 | Joe Mauer#67 | $13BGS 9.5 | — | — | 53.0 |
| #60 | Alex Gordon#15 | $13Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #61 | Evan Longoria#108Photographer's Proof Blue | $11Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #62 | Evan Longoria#108Batting | $11Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #63 | Jay Bruce#171 | $11Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #64 | Jed Lowrie#119Photographer's Proof Gold | $10Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #65 | Max Scherzer#1401st Day Issue Unnumbered | $10Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #66 | Jed Lowrie#119Photographer's Proof Blue | $7Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #67 | Greg Reynolds#120 | $7Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #68 | Joey Votto#112Tossing 1st Day Issue Unnumbered | $7Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #69 | Jed Lowrie#175 | $7Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #70 | Jay Bruce#136 | $6BGS 9.5 | — | — | 54.0 |
| #71 | Matt Joyce#155 | $6Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #72 | Jed Lowrie#119Portrait | $5Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #73 | Joe Mather#183 | $5Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #74 | Brian Barton#172 | $5Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #75 | Babe Ruth#96Photographer's Proof Blue | $5Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #76 | Emmanuel Burriss#151 | $5Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #77 | Darren O'Day#154 | $5Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #78 | Honus Wagner#951st Day Issue | $5Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #79 | Roy Halladay#32 | $5Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #80 | Derek Jeter#59Photographer's Proof Blue | $5Grade 8 | — | — | 47.0 |
| #81 | Ted Williams#99 | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #82 | Dustin Pedroia#55 | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #83 | Ichiro#51Photographer's Proof Gold | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #84 | Carlos Gonzalez#1281st Day Issue | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #85 | Tim Lincecum#2 | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #86 | Miguel Cabrera#26 | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #87 | Jeff Clement#168 | $4Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #88 | Brent Lillibridge#157 | $3Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #89 | Dustin Pedroia#55Photographer's Proof Gold | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #90 | Honus Wagner#95Photographer's Proof Gold | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #91 | David Purcey#110 | $3Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #92 | Evan Longoria#108Photographer's Proof Gold | $3Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #93 | Ryan Braun#80First Day Issue | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #94 | Scott Kazmir#60 | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #95 | Eric Chavez#40 | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #96 | Manny Ramirez#82First Day Issue | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #97 | Alex Gordon#15First Day Issue | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #98 | Jeff Niemann#159 | $3Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #99 | Josh Beckett#45Photographer's Proof Gold | $3Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #100 | Radhames Liz#147 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #101 | Magglio Ordonez#44First Day Issue | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #102 | Derrek Lee#79 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #103 | Blake DeWitt#127 | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #104 | Wladimir Balentien#134 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #105 | Justin Masterson#138First Day Issue | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #106 | Tom Seaver#100 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #107 | Jonathan Albaladejo#177 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #108 | Jay Bruce#1361st Day Issue Unnumbered | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #109 | Chipper Jones#83 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #110 | Hernan Iribarren#1171st Day Issue | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #111 | Alex Rodriguez#13 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #112 | Troy Tulowitzki#361st Day Issue | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #113 | Nick Adenhart#103 | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #114 | Tom Glavine#23 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #115 | Armando Galarraga#124First Day Issue | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #116 | Carlos Gonzalez#128 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #117 | Elliot Johnson#1291st Day Issue | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #118 | Brian McCann#70 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #119 | Mark Teixeira#8 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #120 | Hunter Pence#38Photographer's Proof Gold | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #121 | Todd Helton#4 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #122 | Greg Maddux#73 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #123 | B.J. Upton#17 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #124 | Gary Sheffield#68 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #125 | Clay Buchholz#145 | $2Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #126 | Greg Smith#170 | $2Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #127 | Vladimir Guerrero#61 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #128 | Delmon Young#29 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #129 | John Smoltz#49 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #130 | Gregor Blanco#1041st Day Issue Hitting | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #131 | Ryan Braun#80 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #132 | Jose Reyes#58 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #133 | Grady Sizemore#71 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #134 | Matt Tolbert#121 | $1Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #135 | Magglio Ordonez#44 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |
| #136 | Travis Denker#167 | $1Raw | — | — | 54.0 |
| #137 | Josh Banks#178 | $1Raw | — | — | 53.0 |