| #1 | Mookie Betts#60High Five | $400PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 42.3 |
| #2 | Gerrit Cole#80 | $316PSA 10 | — | 0.0% | 39.3 |
| #3 | Mike Trout#1Hands Up | $102Raw | — | — | 45.5 |
| #4 | Mookie Betts#60Batting Mini Red | $65Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #5 | Bo Jackson#9 | $60PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #6 | Ty Cobb#17Framed White | $54PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #7 | Freddie Freeman#26Knee Up Framed Bronze | $51PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #8 | Nolan Ryan#35 | $50PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #9 | Cal Ripken Jr.#87Framed Bronze | $50PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #10 | Babe Ruth#260 | $45PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #11 | Sandy Koufax#306 | $44BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #12 | Derek Jeter#5Hands Up | $40Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #13 | Willie Mays#100 | $40PSA 10 | — | — | 45.3 |
| #14 | Tom Seaver#311 | $36PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #15 | Phil Rizzuto#316 | $35PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #16 | Duke Snider#303 | $35PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #17 | Ken Griffey Jr.#122Mini | $34PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #18 | Derek Jeter#5Kneeling | $34PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #19 | Javier Baez#91 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #20 | Ozzie Smith#47 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #21 | Don Sutton#36 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #22 | Derek Jeter#5Mini Kneeling Silver | $33BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #23 | John Smoltz#84 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #24 | Jake Peavy#218 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #25 | J.J. Hardy#198 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #26 | Jesse Hahn#300 | $33PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #27 | Mike Mussina#31 | $32PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #28 | David Price#10 | $32PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #29 | Ted Williams#156Mini Silver | $32BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #30 | Jim Palmer#312 | $32PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #31 | Mike Trout#1 | $32PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #32 | Chris Davis#137 | $32PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #33 | Mike Trout#1Mini Red Jersey | $31BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #34 | Jayson Werth#173 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #35 | Gio Gonzalez#76 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #36 | Lou Gehrig#39 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #37 | Larry Doby#142 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #38 | Ernie Banks#133 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #39 | Joe Mauer#66 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #40 | Derek Jeter#5 | $30PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #41 | Derek Jeter#5Kneeling Framed White | $28PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #42 | Wade Boggs#153 | $27PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #43 | Miguel Cabrera#149Green Background | $25Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #44 | Mike Trout#1Mini Holding Bat | $25Grade 8 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #45 | Joey Votto#24 | $25PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #46 | Mike Trout#1Holding Bat Framed White | $23PSA 10 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #47 | Ted Williams#156Mini Gold | $22BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #48 | Craig Biggio#113 | $22PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #49 | Mike Piazza#124 | $22PSA 10 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #50 | Sonny Gray#182Mini | $20Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #51 | Duke Snider#303Mini Silver | $20PSA 10 | — | — | 44.5 |
| #52 | Albert Pujols#49Mini | $19Grade 8 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #53 | Jose Altuve#14Mini Gold | $17BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #54 | George Brett#326 | $16BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #55 | Buster Posey#348Mini Red | $16Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #56 | Yu Darvish#19 | $15Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #57 | Mookie Betts#60Batting Mini | $15Grade 8 | — | — | 45.3 |
| #58 | Jorge Soler#40 | $14PSA 10 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #59 | Derek Jeter#5Mini Kneeling Red | $13Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #60 | Mike Trout#1Holding Bat Framed Bronze | $11BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #61 | Fernando Valenzuela#323Silver Mini | $10Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #62 | Derek Jeter#5Silver Mini | $10Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #63 | Reggie Jackson#319Mini Silver | $10Grade 8 | — | — | 45.3 |
| #64 | Francisco Liriano#220 | $9PSA 10 | — | — | 42.3 |
| #65 | Rickey Henderson#190Silver Mini | $9Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #66 | Derek Jeter#5Mini Kneeling Gold | $8Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #67 | Sandy Koufax#306Mini Gold | $8Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #68 | Chipper Jones#115Silver Mini | $8Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #69 | Mike Trout#1Mini Holding Bat Silver | $7Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #70 | Babe Ruth#260Silver Mini | $7Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #71 | Sparky Anderson#325Mini | $6Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #72 | Brett Gardner#291Silver Mini | $6Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #73 | Sparky Anderson#325Mini Gold | $6Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #74 | Goose Gossage#118Mini Portrait Silver | $6Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #75 | A.J. Burnett#253 | $6Grade 8 | — | — | 45.3 |
| #76 | Javier Baez#91Mini Fielding | $5Grade 8 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #77 | Larry Doby#142Silver Mini | $5Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #78 | Cliff Lee#181Silver Mini | $5Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #79 | Javier Baez#91Mini Fielding Silver | $5Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #80 | Brian Dozier#287 | $5Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #81 | Buster Posey#348Mini | $5Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #82 | Ryne Sandberg#151Silver Mini | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #83 | Willie Stargell#313 | $4BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #84 | Alex Rodriguez#345Mini Gold | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #85 | Bryce Harper#45Mini Batting Gold | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #86 | Sparky Anderson#325Mini Silver | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #87 | Robin Yount#21Silver Mini | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #88 | Hank Aaron#2Framed White | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #89 | Adam Jones#23Mini Batting Gold | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #90 | Dellin Betances#208 | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #91 | Yadier Molina#347 | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #92 | Mookie Betts#60Mini Batting Silver | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #93 | Joe DiMaggio#120Mini Black | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #94 | Jose Altuve#14 | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #95 | Josh Donaldson#81Mini Silver | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #96 | Nolan Ryan#35Mini No Ball | $4Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #97 | Nolan Ryan#35Mini | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #98 | Derek Jeter#5Mini Standing | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #99 | Coco Crisp#229Silver Mini | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #100 | Buster Posey#348 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #101 | Alex Gordon#194 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #102 | Joc Pederson#3Mini Bat Down | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #103 | Eric Davis#329 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #104 | Babe Ruth#260Mini | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #105 | Jacob DeGrom#195Mini Silver | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #106 | Javier Baez#91Fielding Framed White | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #107 | Bryce Harper#45Batting | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #108 | Ken Giles#286Mini Red | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #109 | Bryce Harper#45Batting Framed White | $3BGS 9.5 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #110 | Mike Schmidt#322 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #111 | David Wright#6Mini Red | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #112 | Joc Pederson#3Framed Bronze | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #113 | Al Kaline#310 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #114 | Paul Goldschmidt#16Framed Bronze | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #115 | Gregory Polanco#121Batting | $3PSA 10 | — | — | 50.5 |
| #116 | Carlos Gomez#188 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #117 | Cal Ripken Jr.#87Mini | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #118 | Alex Rodriguez#345Mini Silver | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #119 | Sparky Anderson#325 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #120 | Josh Harrison#272Mini | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #121 | Madison Bumgarner#350 | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #122 | Cal Ripken Jr.#87Framed White | $3Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #123 | Nolan Ryan#35Mini Silver | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #124 | Bill Mazeroski#304 | $2Grade 8 | — | — | 48.3 |
| #125 | Johnny Bench#317 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #126 | Matt Kemp#38Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #127 | Willie Mays#100Framed White | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #128 | Matt Moore#104 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #129 | David Cone#330 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #130 | Koji Uehara#349 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #131 | Paul Konerko#341 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #132 | Willie Mays#100Mini Batting | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #133 | Adam LaRoche#70 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #134 | Lou Brock#307 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #135 | Ben Zobrist#73 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #136 | Mariano Rivera#336 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #137 | J.J. Hardy#198Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #138 | Brooks Robinson#308 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #139 | Satchel Paige#242Framed Bronze | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #140 | Nomar Garciaparra#141Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #141 | Dave Parker#321Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #142 | Allen Craig#273Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #143 | Ryan Howard#154 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #144 | David Ortiz#168 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #145 | Dilson Herrera#171 | $2Raw | — | — | 51.5 |
| #146 | Tom Glavine#18Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #147 | Nick Markakis#69 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #148 | Roger Maris#99Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #149 | Satchel Paige#242Framed White | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #150 | John Olerud#331 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #151 | Reggie Jackson#319 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #152 | Mike Napoli#200 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #153 | Babe Ruth#260Mini Silver | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #154 | Jose Abreu#114Mini Holding Bat | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #155 | Robin Yount#21 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #156 | Mariano Rivera#336Mini Silver | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #157 | Whitey Ford#305 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #158 | Zack Wheeler#131 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #159 | Mat Latos#75 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #160 | Nori Aoki#244 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #161 | Jose Reyes#98 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #162 | Mark Trumbo#289 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #163 | Wade Davis#281 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #164 | Eric Hosmer#67 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #165 | Jake McGee#236 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #166 | Rymer Liriano#158 | $2Raw | — | — | 51.5 |
| #167 | Chase Utley#174 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #168 | Dan Haren#274 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #169 | Ian Kinsler#167 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #170 | Jon Lester#89 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #171 | Tim Hudson#130 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #172 | Tyson Ross#235 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #173 | Zach Britton#255Mini Gold | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #174 | Matt Kemp#38 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #175 | Todd Frazier#15 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #176 | Mookie Wilson#82Framed Bronze | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #177 | Felix Hernandez#150 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #178 | Joe Mauer#66Silver Mini | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #179 | Yan Gomes#257 | $2Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #180 | Evan Gattis#112 | $1Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #181 | Adam Jones#23 | $1Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #182 | David Wright#6 | $1Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #183 | Maikel Franco#4 | $1Raw | — | — | 51.5 |
| #184 | Yasiel Puig#176 | $1Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #185 | Coco Crisp#229 | $1Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #186 | Gary Carter#320 | $1Raw | — | — | 50.5 |
| #187 | Mike Foltynewicz#259 | $1Raw | — | — | 51.5 |
| #188 | Dave Parker#321 | $1Grade 8 | — | — | 44.5 |