Jul 4, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Nightmare Fourth Edition MTG Magic The Gathering Card LP Jun 22, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Magic the Gathering MTG ~ Nightmare ~ Fourth Edition ~ 4Ed ~ MP - FREE SHIPPING Jun 22, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare Rare Fourth Edition Magic: The Gathering Damaged Jun 17, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare Rare Fourth Edition Magic: The Gathering Lightly Played Jun 8, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare - 4th Edition - Moderately Played | MTG Jun 7, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Nightmare 4th Edition Black Rare Magic The Gathering MTG Jun 7, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Nightmare 4th Edition Black Rare Magic The Gathering MTG Jun 7, 2026 Ungraded $6 e b a y
Nightmare (NM) Fourth Edition 4ED Magic MTG May 19, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Magic the Gathering ~ MTG ~ Nightmare ~ Fourth Edition ~ 4Ed ~ MP May 19, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare - 4th Edition - Lightly Played - MTG May 13, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
Nightmare 4th Edition HP MTG May 13, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare 1x MtG 4th Edition HEAVY PLAYED May 13, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
Nightmare [Fourth Edition] MTG Core Set English Regular NM *Actual Pictures May 8, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare - 4th Edition - Moderately Played | MTG May 1, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Nightmare 4th Edition HEAVILY PLD Black Rare MAGIC THE GATHERING CARD ABUGames May 1, 2026 SGC 7 $40 e b a y
Nightmare MTG Core Set 4th Edition Regular SGC 7 Near Mint Apr 20, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Magic the Gathering ~ MTG ~ Nightmare ~ Fourth Edition ~ 4Ed ~ LP Apr 13, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
NIGHTMARE x1 mtg NM 4th Edition 1 Rare UNPLAYED #150 Mar 29, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Nightmare R Fourth Edition 4ED Normal MTG LP Mar 25, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Magic The Gathering - Nightmare - 1995 4th Edition Mar 23, 2026 Ungraded $12 e b a y
Nightmare - 4th Edition *NM* Near Mint MTG - PSA QUALITY Mar 12, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
1995 Magic: The Gathering MTG - 4th Edition- NIGHTMARE - Vintage Rare Feb 25, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
MTG Nightmare, Fourth Edition, Damaged, English 150/379 Feb 16, 2026 Ungraded $2 e b a y
Magic the Gathering ~ MTG ~ Nightmare ~ Fourth Edition ~ 4Ed ~ LP Feb 14, 2026 Ungraded $4 e b a y
MTG - Magic The Gathering - Nightmare - 4th Edition- NP/NM! Feb 4, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
Nightmare 4th Edition LP MTG Jan 25, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
MTG Magic the Gathering Nightmare (150/379) Fourth Edition LP Jan 16, 2026 Ungraded $8 e b a y
Nightmare (Fourth Edition (4ED) Magic Card MTG English (Nachtmahr) Jan 11, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Magic the Gathering ~ MTG ~ Nightmare ~ Fourth Edition ~ 4Ed ~ M/NM Jan 3, 2026 Ungraded $3 e b a y
Nightmare R Fourth Edition 4ED Normal MTG MP Jan 2, 2026 Ungraded $1 e b a y
MTG Magic the Gathering Nightmare (150/379) Fourth Edition HP Aug 26, 2025 BGS 9 $51 e b a y
***BGS 9 Quad++ Nightmare*** MTG 4th Edition Magic Kid Icarus Apr 4, 2025 PSA 9 $140 e b a y
MTG 1995 Alternate Alt 4th Edition - Nightmare - PSA 9 Mint - POP 1 Nov 27, 2024 CGC 7 $50 e b a y
NIGHTMARE 4th Edition Alternate Rare CGC 7 Vintage MTG [Nostalgium] Aug 20, 2024 CGC 9 $25 e b a y
NIGHTMARE 4th Edition Rare CGC 9 Mint Vintage MTG [Nostalgium] Jul 22, 2024 PSA 9 $80 e b a y
⚫️⚫️⚫️ 1995 Magic The Gathering NIGHTMARE 4TH Edition PSA 9 ⚫️⚫️⚫️ #NA May 28, 2024 CGC 10 $168 e b a y
***CGC 10 Nightmare Alternate 4th Edition*** MTG Magic Kid Icarus 
